EP0000091B1

EP0000091B1 - Improved pressure release closure

Info

Publication number: EP0000091B1
Application number: EP78300012A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Michael Debenham; Allan George Dalli; Peter Lewis Revill
Original assignee: Broken Hill Pty Co Ltd
Current assignee: Broken Hill Pty Co Ltd
Priority date: 1977-06-10
Filing date: 1978-06-02
Publication date: 1983-09-07
Also published as: DK225578A; CA1094472A; PT68094A; IE48027B1; DK152026B; DK152026C; MX145578A; NZ187328A; EP0000091A1; ES476362A1; NO781797L; FI781599A; FI68580C; GR68086B; IE781011L; ZA782900B; JPS5440783A; NO154225B; ES470541A1; JPS621899B2

Description

This invention relates to improvements in easy opening closures, and more particularly to improvements in pressure releasing vent closures of the type presently used in can ends having push-in closures.
It is generally accepted in the can making art that a can having push-in closures requires, for highly carbonated beverages, some form of pressure releasing venting closure by means of which the pressure within the can may be at least reduced prior to opening the pouring closure. An example of a pressure releasing venting closure is shown in Figure 1 of the accompanying drawings, in which it will be noted that the venting closure V is smaller in area than the pouring closure P.
Cans containing highly carbonated beverages, including those having venting closures as shown in Figure 1, are liable to gush or spurt on being opened, especially where the beverage in the can tends to froth. The problem is aggravated when the can is tilted during the opening operation since this often means that the liquid in the can is close to or covers the venting closure whereby the escaping gas is more likely to entrain some of the liquid or froth in the can. The problem is even more aggravated where the can is roughly handled prior to the opening thereof since agitation causes the release of carbon dioxide into the can head space, thereby generating froth.
U.S. Patent 2,261,117 to Jack, Jr., discloses a push-in closure comprising a single closure member. The closure member is formed by forming a bulge in the container member, severing around the bulge to form a severed bulged tab, and then flattening the bulged tab to place the cut edges thereof and the marginal portions surrounding the opening in overlapping relationship. A seal is formed between the overlapped portions. One embodiment of the invention provides a closure member which can be used on a container for a carbonated beverage but the closure member does not reseal after it has been opened by the application of a digitally applied push-in force. The second embodiment is for a closure member which can reseal after it has been opened by the application of a digitally applied push-in force but this form of closure member is not suitable for use on a container for a carbonated beverage.
U.S. Patent 3,334,775 to Klein et al. discloses a gated can lid wherein the gate is depressible into the container by digitally applied push-in force. The container has a single gate therein, but the patentees describe, at column 4, lines 62-66, an arrangement wherein a portion of the gate panel might be folded inwardly from each end to provide a specific pouring portion and a venting portion, with the section of the gate panel between these portions remaining in position. Klein et al. do not disclose or suggest a resealable venting member.
U.S. Patent 3,741,432 to Werth et al. and Australian Patent No. 475,951 each disclose a closure tab for a container, with a pressure release tab formed in the closure tab. Manual pressure applied to the pressure release vent tab is transferred to the closure tab. Both the release vent tab and the closure tab are depressible by the pressure of the user's thumb applied to the release vent closure tab and transmitted to the closure tab in a single operation which first exposes the release vent and then the closure or vent opening. Werth et al. have no suggestion that the pressure release vent tab disclosed therein is resealable upon the release of digitally applied push-in force. As a matter of fact, the entire thrust of the Werth et al. patent is to permit the pressure to be vented and the pouring opening to be opened in one operation without withdrawing a digit from the tab area.
U.S. Patent 3,958,717 to Ellis discloses a push-in, easy opening closure which includes a pouring tab and a vent tab. The tabs are integrally connected to the can lid by a hinge area, and share a common hinge area, with the tabs extending in opposite direction from the common hinge area. The patentees indicate that this construction results in an appearance similar to a conventional ring-pull end, so special instructions would not be required to educate the consumer, and also with the tabs located immediately adjacent to each other the can can be opened with a minimum of finger movement. There is no suggestion that the vent tab reseals itself upon the removal of finger pressure applied thereto.
U.S. Patent No. 4,033,275 to Radtke discloses a beverage can end having a vent tab and a pour tab, generally similar to the design of U.S. Patent No. 3,958,717, except the tabs do not share a common hinge area, but instead are disclosed as remote from one another.
It is thus an object of the present invention to provide improved forms of pressure releasing closure by means of which the gushing or spurting problem described above is at least alleviated or made more controllable.
The present invention provides a push-in pressure releasing closure in a container member suitable for liquids under pressure comprising a closure member formed integrally from a portion of the container member and defined by at least a weakening line and being of dimensions capable of being opened by a digitally applied push-in force against the action of said pressure, said closure member having an operating portion which is adapted in use to have said push-in force applied thereto and a connection to said container member, characterised in that means are provided for substantially preventing permanent opening of said closure member by an unrestrained digitally applied push-in force whereby said closure member substantially returns to its closed position in the absence of said digitally applied push-in force to such an extent as to inhibit the escape of froth and/or liquid under pressure from within said container member.
The invention also provides a can end for a container suitable for liquids under pressure, including a liquid pouring closure and a pressure releasing closure in said end to be opened by a digitally applied push-in force characterised in that said pressure releasing closure co-operates with the portion of the can end surrounding said pressure releasing closure to physically limit the unrestrained depression of said pressure releasing closure by said digitally applied push-in force to cause said pressure releasing closure to return substantially to its closed position in the absence of said digitally applied push-in force to such an extent as to inhibit the escape of froth and/or liquid under pressure from within said container.
It will be appreciated from the above that since the closure member does not remain open except when the push-in force is applied to the operating portion, gushing or spurting will not be allowed to continue when the force is removed. Furthermore, since the push-in force must be applied to keep the closure member open, the finger or thumb applying the force will act to deflect any liquid or gas coming from the closure.
In the case of the prior art arrangement shown in Figure 1, the tendence is for the person opening the closure to have removed his finger from the closure before spurting commences, leaving, in the extreme situation, the spurting liquid free to create a fountain.
The improved pressure releasing closure may be achieved in several ways. For example, the extent to which the operating portion is raised and/or the effective area of the pressure releasing closure member available for actuation may be selected so as to prevent deflection by a digitally applied force beyond the angle at which the elastic limit of the metal at said connection is exceeded, thereby preventing permanent opening of the closure member by finger or thumb pressure. Alternatively, the connection may be arranged at a remote position relative to the operating portion compared to the prior art arrangement, in which the hinge is right at the periphery of the operating portion, and the closure member cannot be opened sufficiently to deform beyond its elastic limit the metal defining the connection.
In one particularly preferred form of the invention, the pressure releasing closure is formed at the narrow end of a generally pear shaped pouring closure hinged to the container end about its wide end, said pressure releasing closure being partly severed from said pouring closure except for a narrow connection about which the pressure releasing closure flexes during the pressure releasing opening thereof, said pressure releasing closure being raised to such an extent or being of an effective size such as to prevent permanent opening thereof by finger or thumb pressure.
In the case of the arrangement shown in Fig. 1, the thumb or finger is likely to cover the hole formed on opening the venting closure. This has been found to result in undesirable opening characteristics being introduced by the user since the tendency is for the user to remove the thumb or finger as soon as gas escape is detected. With the preferred arrangement described above, the escape of gas can occur as soon as the closure is opened while the escape of spurting liquid can be prevented by releasing the opening force on the closure member, and controlled escape achieved by releasing the gas and/or froth in short bursts.
In another preferred form of the invention, the pressure releasing closure member is formed as an extension on a pouring closure, with the openings being closed by the respective closures preferably being interconnected to form a single opening. In this arrangement, the pressure releasing closure operates in the manner described above but is removed from its opening when the pouring closure is opened thus providing a venting opening by means of which the contents of the can may be vented during the pouring operation.
In another preferred embodiment of the present invention, the operating portion is located at one end of a relatively narrow elongated portion extending from the connection to the container member. With this arrangement it is unlikely that the finger or thumb applying the opening force will completely cover the whole of the closure thus leaving an escape path for the gases being released from the container.
For all of the embodiments of the present invention, it is critical that the closure not be depressed into the opening with which the closure is associated to an extent as to exceed the elastic limit thereof. By causing the closure to depress into the beverage can or other container upon the application of digitally applied push-in force thereto, with flexing of the closure about the connection, without exceeding the elastic limit of the connection, the closure will be returned at least substantially to its original position, thereby to reseal the container against further escape of froth or liquid therefrom. The internal pressure within the container aids in the resealing of the closure.
The exact amount of depression which a given closure can experience without the elastic limit of the connection thereof being exceeded will depend upon a number of variables, such as the size of the closure, the thickness of the metal, the type of the metal, the effective length of the connection, and the like. Generally, it is not possible to specify an exact amount of closure deflection which can be encountered before the elastic limit of the connection is exceeded. However, in general terms the amount of angular depression of the closure may be more readily appreciated from consideration of the following simulated test.
A closure was formed in a sheet of 5082 Aluminum, having a thickness of 0.15 inches. The closure was of the design set forth in Figure 6, with the central cut being located 0.016 inches from the center of the closure. The free or cut edges of the sides of the closure were located approximately 0.015 inches from the center of the closure. The end of the closure furthest removed from the connection was deflected into the simulated can a distance of 0.030 inches, corresponding to an angular deflection of 5.5°, and upon removal of the deflecting pressure the closure returned to approximately its original position. A deflection of 0.035 inches still resulted in the return of the closure to approximately its original position - that is, the elastic limit of the connection was not exceeded. However, upon depressing the closure a distance of 0.040 inches corresponding to an angular deflection of 7.5°, permanent deformation of the connection occurred, and the closure would not return to its original position.
This simulated test was conducted by clamping the closure at the hinge line, with the application of force applied to the free edge of the closure which was furthest removed from the hinge line.
Based on the results of this test, it appears that the angular displacement of the closure must be less than 7.5°, and preferably no more than 5.5 to 6.0°. Of course, the depression must be sufficient to permit the escape of pressure from the container interior, and the minimum deflection which will accomplish this result will depend upon a number of variables, including the thickness and type of the sealant applied to the line of severance.
In actual use by consumers, whose opening habits may vary widely, it may be possible to occasionally obtain some slight permanent deformation of the connection or hinge, but this deformation would be unusual (perhaps caused by excessively strong consumer) and should be minimized by the internal pressure of the can, especially when carbonated or malt beverages are contained therein.
In order that the invention may be more readily understood, several preferred embodiments of the invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:

Figure 1 is a plan view of a can end according to the prior art;
Figure 2 is a plan view of a simple embodiment which demonstrates the principle of operation thereof in comparison with the prior art end;
Figure 3 is a plan view of one preferred practical realisation of the invention;
Figure 4 is an enlarged fragmentary sectional elevation of the end of Figure 3 taken along the line 4-4 in Figure 3;
Figure 5 is a schematic fragmentary sectional elevation of die components suitable for forming the closure shown in the Figures 3 and 4;
Figure 6 is a plan view of a modified form of the embodiment of Figure 3;
Figure 7 is a plan view of another preferred realisation of the invention;
Figure 8 is an enlarged fragmentary sectional elevation taken along the line 8-8 in Figure 7,
Figure 9 is a plan view of yet another form of the invention;
Figure 10 is an enlarged sectional elevation along the line 10-10 in Figure 9;
Figure 11 is a fragmentary plan view of a modification of the embodiment of Figure 9;
Figure 12 is a schematic representation of one of the stages in the formation of the closure of Figures 9 and 10;
Figure 13 is a schematic view similar to Figure 12 showing a modified formation method;
Figure 14 is a plan view of a still further preferred realisation of the invention;
Figure 15 is a sectional elevation taken along the line 15-15 in Figure 14; and
Figure 16 is a fragmentary sectional elevation of the closure of Figures 12 and 13 formed in a depressed area in a flat end panel.

Referring firstly to Figure 1 of the drawings, the prior art can end shown in Figure 1 has a pressure releasing/venting closure V and a pouring closure P. Each closure is circular and is integrally hinged at H to the can end at the periphery of the closures. Thus when the closures V and P are opened, they hinge about H and since the opening force deflects the closures to such an angle that the elastic limit of the metal forming hinge H is exceeded the closure will remain open once opened. In the case of closure V, the tab thereof is raised more than the pouring tab to ensure that it can be pushed open to such an extent as to permit adequate venting of the can during pouring.
In the simple or schematic embodiment of the invention shown in Figure 2, the venting closure V is replaced by a pressure releasing closure 10. The closure 10 comprises a closure member or tab 11 having an operating portion 12 in the form of an upwardly raised button by means of which an opening force can be applied to the closure 10 by a finger or thumb. The tab 11 has a relatively elongate narrow configuration compared to the venting closure V and is integrally connected to the end at 13. The connection 13 does not act as a hinge in use in the same manner as hinges H in Figure 1 operate, and for this reason the connection is described as a connection rather than a hinge.
The closure member 11 is of the fully sheared construction described in U.S. Patents No. Re. 28,910 (3,759,206) and 3,931,909, and is formed by the method disclosed therein, or by coining or otherwise expanding the tab and/or by contracting the size of the opening by means of any suitable cold working operation such as coining.
During opening, a force is applied to the raised portion 12 by means of a finger or thumb. Since the connection 13 is remote from the portion 12, it is unlikely that the whole of the closure will be covered by the finger and gas escape openings will be exposed at least along the long sides of the tab 11. Furthermore, the remote positioning of the connection 13 means that the angle to which the tab 11 can be deflected by a digitally applied force will not be so great as to exceed the elastic limit of the metal at the connection 13 so the tab will resume at least substantially its closed position on removal of the opening force. This will of course be assisted by any pressure within the can or by escaping contents. These two factors combined means that in the event that spurting does occur, it can be controlled by means of the closure 10 by removing the opening force and releasing the gas and/or froth in short bursts.
In practical embodiments the closure 10 is likely to be positioned closer to the centre of the can end to reduce the likelihood of liquid being present in the gas released from the can. Furthermore, it will be appreciated that in any commercial embodiment the closures 10 and P will be hermetically sealed by means of sealant (not shown), such as a plastisol, applied to the end in any suitable manner.
Notwithstanding the ability of the above embodiment to at least reduce the problems associated with the prior art, the arrangement does have one practical disadvantage in that the closure 10, upon the release of the push-in opening force, no longer acts to vent air into the can during the pouring or drinking of liquid therefrom. The problem can however be overcome by adopting any one of the closure configurations shown in Figures 3 to 14 of the drawings.
The can end shown in Figures 3 and 4 is formed with a fully sheared closure member surrounded by a generally pear-shaped opening 21 and is hinged to the end at 22. The tab 20 is formed with a raised area 23 extending from the wide end of the tab 20 and a smaller raised area or button 24 adjacent the narrow end of the tab 20. The narrow end of the tab 20 is partly severed from the remainder of the tab 20 along lines 25 and 26 leaving a narrow connection 27 and thereby defining a pressure releasing tab 28. The button 24 in tab 28 is raised to a greater extent than the area 23 so as to be more readily accessible for finger or thumb actuation. For example the tab 28 may be raised by about 1 mm above the periphery of the tab 20 and it will be noted from the drawing that the tab 20 is level with the raised periphery of the opening 21.
The lines of severance 25, 26 allow the pressure releasing tab 28 to be flexed about connection 27 while the height of the tab 28 is selected to prevent permanent deflection after removal of the opening force applied by a finger or thumb. When the opening force is removed, the tab 28 will close to prevent continued spurting in the event that spurting occurs. Once the pressure in the can has been released, the closure 20 is easily opened by finger pressure applied to the raised area 23 of tab 20. As in the earlier embodiment, sealant (not shown) is applied to cover all lines of severance in the closure.
It is desirable, both the protect the tabs 20 and 28 against unintentional opening, and to stiffen the end against outward buckling under pressure, to form the closure within a depressed area 29 formed in the end. The depressed area 29 may be formed by slightly doming the end panel, say by about 1.5 mm, and then flattening the dome to form the area 29. Alternatively, a flat end panel may be formed with the depressed area 29. In this way the tabs 20 and 28 are protected by the upstanding portion 30 of the end panel and the panel is stiffened against outward buckling.
It will be appreciated from a consideration of the above description that the embodiment of Figure 3 effectively combines the separate pressure releasing tab of Figure 2 and a pouring tab, with the tab 20 itself defining the connection between the pressure releasing tab 28 and the can end. By effectively joining the pressure releasing opening and tab to the pouring opening and tab, the venting opening is opened when the tab 20 is opened thereby overcoming the problem created by the resealing nature of the pressure releasing tab 28. However, until the tab 20 is opened, the pressure releasing tab acts in the same manner as described above and therefore alleviates the problems associated with the prior art at least to the same extent as the first embodiment.
The configuration of the opening 21 results in acceptable pouring and drinking characteristics.
The closure is formed by a modified version of the method described in the patents referred to above. It is not practical under high speed end forming conditions to sever the tab 20 and to form the slits 25 and 26 are separate die stations.
Thus, it is preferred to form a closure tab having lines of severance extending generally transversely to the line of severance of the tab itself by severing the metal along said transverse lines by means of stepped punch and a spring biased die member slidably located within the main die member for severing the tab said spring biased die member being pushed into the main die member as the main severing operation takes place.
In use the stepped punch initially severs the sheet metal along said transverse lines and partly severs the adjacent portion of the tab. Then the slidable die member is pushed into the die whereupon the remainder of the tab is severed.
An apparatus suitable for forming the closure is shown schematically in Figure 5 which is a fragmentary schematic sectional elevation of the die components. The die includes a main die member 40 having a cutting face 41 in the shape of the opening 21, and a die member 42 slidably mounted within the main die 40 and biased towards the position shown by means of a spring 43. The slidable member 42 is formed with two cutting faces 44, only one of which is shown, for forming the lines of severance 25,26. A stepped punch 45 having cutting faces 46 corresponding to the cutting faces 44 is arranged to initially engage the slidable member 42 to sever along the lines 25 and 26 and to sever the perimeter of the pressure releasing tab 28. The punch 45 then pushes the slidable member 42 into the die 40 whereupon the punch 45 severs the remainder of the tab 20 from the end.
The sheet metal displaced by severing along the lines 25, 26 is returned to the same plane as the remaining metal to ensure that the periphery of the tab is substantially planar. If necessary the metal on either side of each line of severance may be coined to ensure that the slits do not open up.
If necessary the edge of the tab 20 and/or the periphery of the opening 21 may be coined or otherwise worked to increase the overlap between the tab 20 and the surrounding metal.
A modification of the closure of Figures 3 and 4 is shown in Figure 6. In this modification, the lines of severance 25, 26 are replaced by a central line of severance 25' leaving two spaced connections 27' between the pressure releasing tab 28' and the main tab 20'. The closure is otherwise identical to the embodiment of Figures 3 and 4 and operates in exactly the same manner. However, it has the advantages of having an unsevered periphery and being more resistant to leakage than the embodiment of Figure 3, wherein leakage may occur if the lines of severance 25, 26 are displaced. Furthermore, the unsevered periphery of the closure of Figure 6 results in a less complex die operation in the closure fabrication. In this instance, the central line of severance may be formed by a so- called "offset shear" die operation.
The closure of Figure 6 is formed in the following manner. The end panel is outwardly domed by about 1.5 mm by a die operation or by coining around the periphery of the end panel adjacent the countersink. The area in which the closure is formed is flattened and the sheet metal raised in the region in which the pressure releasing tab 28' is to be formed. The tab 20' is then severed and the initial bulging operation described in the above patents is performed. At the same time, the tab 20' is raised by a form punch and the metal locally sheared along a line around an edge of the form punch. The bulged metal around the opening is then flattened to form an overlap between the tab and surrounding metal and sealant is applied along all lines of severance.
If necessary, the metal on either side of the line may be coined to ensure that the line does not open. Alternatively, the form punch may be notched so that the line is interrupted over a short distance. Of course, instead of shearing along a line, a line of weakness, such as a score line, may perform the same function. Once again the periphery of the tab and/or the metal surrounding the opening may be coined to increase the overlap between the tab and the surrounding metal.
The can end shown in Figures 7 and 8 is formed with a fully sheared closure comprising a pouring closure member or tab 31 hinged to the end at 32 and underlying a pouring opening 33, and a pressure releasing venting closure member or tab 34 secured to the pouring tab by means of an integral neck 35 and extending radially therefrom to underlie a venting opening 36 which opens into the pouring opening 33 over the neck 35. The tabs 31 and 34 are upwardly raised with the tab 34 being raised to a greater extent so as to be more readily accessible to finger or thumb. For example the tab 34 may be raised by about 1 mm above the periphery of the tab and it will be noted from the drawing that the tab 31 is level with the raised periphery of the opening 33.
The closure described above is formed by the same method as the closure 10. If necessary the edge of each tab 31 and 34 and/or the periphery of each opening 33 and 36 may be coined or otherwise worked to increase the overlap between the tabs and the surrounding metal.
The embodiment of Figures 7 and 8 effectively combines the separate pressure releasing tab of Figure 2 and a known pouring tab, with the tab 31 defining the connection between the pressure releasing tab 34 and the can end. In use, the venting opening 36 is opened when the pouring tab 31 is depressed thereby overcoming the problem created by the resealing nature of the pressure releasing tab 34. However, until the pouring tab 31 is depressed, the pressure releasing tab acts in the same manner as described above and therefore alleviates the problems associated with the prior art at least to the same extent as the first embodiment.
To both protect the tab 34 against unintentional opening and to stiffen the end against outward buckling under pressure a raised rib R is formed in the end, for example in the form shown in Figures 7 and 8. The configuration and placement of the rib in the manner shown in the drawings is not essential to the invention since many other configurations and positionings of one or more ribs or beads are envisaged as being just as effective for the purposes described. It will also be appreciated that similar protective rib(s) may be incorporated into the arrangement shown in Figure 2 of the drawings.
The positioning of the hinge 32 as shown in Figure 7 is also not essential or even necessarily most preferred. The hinge may be located at the position shown in Figure 3 of the drawings or directly opposite the position shown in Figure 7.
Similarly the particular configuration of the combined openings 33 and 36 is not essential to the invention. The smoothly rounded nature of the opening over the neck 35 is preferred for aesthetic and practical reasons and it is believed that the configuration shown would provide good drinking and pouring performances.
The can end shown in Figures 9 and 10 of the drawings has a fully sheared closure member or tab 50 which overlaps with and underlies the metal surrounding a generally pear shaped opening 51 and is hinged to the end at 52. The tab 50 has a central area 53 which is raised with respect to the periphery of the tab. However, it will be noted that the raised area 53 is at the same general level as the sheet metal defining the hinge 52 whereby the hinge metal is substantially undeformed by the closure forming process which will be defined in more detail below. Tests carried out to date appear to suggest that the undisturbed nature of the metal at the hinge 52 may well increase the pressure at which peaking or buckling of the end will occur in this general area of the end.
The tab 50 has a pressure releasing closure member or tab 55 formed therein in the manner shown in Figures 9 and 10 of the drawings. The tab 55 is formed with an upwardly raised button 56 at the end of a relatively elongate narrow area of metal defining the tab. The tab is connected to the sheet metal defining the tab 50 at 57 and overlaps with and underlies the sheet metal surrounding the sheared opening 58. Both closures are hermetically sealed by means of a sealant (not shown) and the pressure releasing closure operates in the same manner as the pressure releasing closures described above. However, it will be appreciated that in most opening operations the two closures will be opened by means of a single unidirectional push-in force applied in the general area of the raised button 56 on the pressure releasing tab 55. Of course, in the situations described above it may be necessary to actuate the pressure releasing closure several times. However, it should not be necessary for the user to relocate his or her digit for the final opening operation in which the tab 50 is fully opened. If desired the tab 55 may be located in an inverted position adjacent the narrow end of tab 50 to ensure that relocation of the digit is not required during the opening of tab 50.
A further modification of the embodiment of Figure 9 is shown in Figure 11. In this closure tab arrangement, the pouring tab 50' has an oblate configuration and is located in an inverted position with its hinge 52' located near the centre of the can end. The pressure releasing tab 55' is located within a depressed region 54' in the tab 50' to protect the tab 56' but is otherwise substantially identical to the tab 55.
The arrangement of the tabs 50' and 55' in this manner has the advantage of locating the tab 55' nearer to the centre of the can end where the headspace is likely to be greater. The can end is formed with an indentation surrounding the closure 50'. This serves as a sealant well when sealant is applied to the closure 50' and also allows the sheet metal to be clamped to inhibit metal migration when the sheet metal around the opening 51' is coined to create overlap.
The above embodiments of the invention are similar in construction to the closure described in U.S. Patent No. 3,741,432 Werth et al. with the exception that the pressure releasing tab 55 is formed in accordance with the present invention rather than in the manner shown in the U.S. Patent. Thus, the closure shown in Figures 9 and 10 will have the same advantages over the Werth et al. closure as the previous embodiments have over the prior art shown in Figure 1. Furthermore, the use of a common hinge area, as shown in Figures 1 and 3 of the Werth et al. patent, may have disadvantages in that the depression of the pouring tab 15 causes further depression of tab 21 thereby increasing the likelihood of the hinge fracturing to detach the tab 21 from the can end.
It will be noted from Figures 9 and 10 of the drawings that the can end incorporating the improved closure has an outwardly domed central panel 60. Although it is not readily apparent from the drawing, the dome is slightly flat topped for a reason to be described below. The closures 50 and 55 are formed in a downwardly depressed area 61 which extends into the domed end from the hinge area 52 in the same general configuration as the tab 50. The location of the closures 50 and 55 within the depressed area 61 protects the closure 50 against unintentional actuation and to a lesser extent the closure 55 is similarly protected against unintentional actuation.
The slight flattening of the dome formed in the end panel 60 increases the height of the dome in the region in which the pressure releasing tab 55 is to be formed thereby increasing the amount of protection afforded to the tab 55 by the adjacent areas of the end panel 60.
It will be noted from the sectional elevation of Figure 10 that the top of the button 56 is located at the same general level as the surrounding sheet metal of the central panel.
The end panel 60 is also preferably domed for the following reasons. The doming of the end panel increases the head space of a can to which the end is fitted. The doming of the end panel also increases the rigidity of the end panel. Finally, it is believed that the doming of the end panel will usefully enhance the buckle strength of the converted end. In tests carried out on plain ends it was found that the doming of the end panel between about 1.5 mm and about 3.0 mm increased the buckle strength of the end. Improvement in the buckle strength increased as doming increased.
The closures 50 and 55, and 50' and 55', may be formed in a can end blank by any suitable method of piercing and reforming the sheet metal of the end blank. Under normal circumstances the method used would involve several separate die operations, and the punch/die sets used would require the usual stripper plates and die ejectors for ensuring separation between sheet metal and the punch and die components. The use of stripper plates and die ejectors complicates the punch/die sets and the desirability of reducing the number of die operations is obvious.
One preferred method of forming the improved closure will now be described. In a first operation the end panel is formed with a slightly flat topped dome. In a second operation the dome is downwardly depressed to form the area 61 and to form a small dimple in the region in which the button 56 is to be formed. The dimple is then reformed into the flat topped button 56 by flattening the top of the dimple between two die members. In a fourth operation the tabs 50 and 55 are sheared and in the same operation the periphery of the tab 50 is reformed downwardly to form the upwardly raised area 53. This operation is shown schematically in Figure 12 which is a fragmentary sectional view across the tab 50 but excluding the tab 55. As mentioned above, the central portion of the tab remains at the same general level as the unsheared metal defining the hinge 52. In a fifth stage the height of the shoulder of metal defined by the sheared portion of the sides of the area 61 is reduced and the angle of the side to the end panel increased to produce some overlap between sheet metal surrounding the opening and the tab 50. Finally, the periphery of the tab is coined to increase the area of the tab and further increase the overlap between the tab and the sheet metal surrounding the opening. The sheet metal surrounding the opening 58 is also coined to produce overlap between the opening and the pressure releasing tab 55. The coining of the periphery of the tab 50 is preferably performed at a position close to the shoulder of the raised area 53 so that most of the metal expansion is in the outward direction rather than back towards the centre of the tab. To avoid excessive curling of the periphery of the tab during this operation, the edge of the tab is firmly clinched by die members. Each of the above operations will be well known to persons skilled in the art and are therefore not shown in detail in the drawings.
It will be appreciated that in the above description some of the formation stages have been artificially separated for purposes of clarity. In any practical conversion of the can end certain of the stages may be combined within a single die operation or separated from the stages described above. For example, the formation of the dimple may need to be performed in a separate stage.
The above method of forming the improved closure has several advantages. Firstly, formation of the closure within the downwardly depressed area 61 in the domed central panel provides protection against unintentional opening of the closure. SecondIy, the downward reforming of the periphery of the tab 50 enables its central portion to remain at the same level as the hinge 52 and it is believed that this may well improve the pressure performance of the converted end. This method of forming the tab 50 also enables the pressure releasing tab 55 to be sheared from the tab 50 in the same die operation without any undesirable deformation of the tab 50. To form the same type of closure combination in a flat or upwardly raised area of metal, the shearing of the tabs may result in downward turning of the edges of the larger tab which may need to be flattened or restored in a subsequent die operation.
While the above described method of formation reduces the number of formation stages, it has been discovered that the piercing of the tabs 50 and 55 can also be combined with the reforming of the sheet metal surrounding the openings to form the downwardly depressed area 61 surrounding the closure 50 and the formation of the button 56. This single die operation is shown schematically in Figure 13 which is a fragmentary sectional view across the punch/die set in the region of tab 50 but excluding tab 55. It will be noted that the punch P is formed with a shoulder and a central recess, while the die D is formed with cooperating shoulders and recesses to facilitate the downward reforming of the tab 50 and the surround 61.
It has been found that the single operation piercing and reforming not only reduces the number of die stages but also removes the need for stripper plates and die ejectors. The resulting tab and opening are found to be substantially the same size after the piercing/reforming operation and accordingly they do not stick in the die or on the punch.
The above method still has the advantage of maintaining the central portion of the tab 50 at the same general level as the unpierced metal defining the hinge.
In the second operation, the sheet metal around the periphery of the tabs 50 and 55 and the sheet metal around opening 51 are coined to create the necessary overlap between the tabs 50 and 55 and the sheet metal surrounding them. Alternatively, the overlap can be achieved by the other methods described above. Following this, sealant is applied in the regions of the cut edges of the tabs 50 and 55 to hermetically seal the two closures.
The above method of forming the improved closure is preferred for several reasons. Firstly the piercing and reforming operations are performed in one die stage thereby reducing the number of stages and excluding tre stripper plates and die ejectors. Secondly, formation of the closure within the downwardly depressed area 61 in the central panel provides protection against unintentional opening of the closure. Thirdly, the downwardly reforming of the periphery of the tab 50 enables its central portion to remain at the same level as the hinge 52 and it is believed that this may well improve the pressure performance of the converted end. This method of forming the tab 50 also enables the pressure releasing tab 55 to be sheared from the tab 50 in the same die operation without any undesirable deformation of the tab 50. To form the same type of closure combination in a flat or upwardly raised area of metal, the shearing of the tabs may result in downward turning of the edges of the larger tab which may need to be flattened or restored in a subsequent die operation.
It will be appreciated that in forming the closure arrangement shown in Figure 11 the downward reforming of the sheet metal surrounding the tab 55' will be performed in the first die operation. This method may also be used to form the modifications to be described below.
It will be appreciated that other methods of formation may well be used with equally acceptable results. For example, the sheet metal surrounding the opening 51 may be coined to increase the overlap between the tab 50 and the surround. Alternatively, the overlap between the tab 50 and the surround may be produced solely by suitably reforming the shoulder referred to above. The overlap between the pressure releasing closure 55 and the surrounding sheet metal is preferably formed as described above since this enables the button 56 to be made larger and to be located closer to the periphery of the opening 58. However, the necessary overlap may be produced by coining the periphery of the tab 55.
It will be appreciated that the various closure members described in the earlier embodiments may be formed in substantially the same manner as the modified closure described in the above embodiment. For example, in the embodiments of Figures 3 and 6, the size of the depressed areas may be reduced to the same size as the area 61 and the upstand surrounding the opening may be flattened as shown in Figure 10. In the case of the embodiments of Figures 7 and 8, the location of the closure within a depressed area would remove the need to form the protective rib R.
The embodiment of the invention shown in Figures 14 and 15 is a modification of the embodiment of Figures 3 and 4 and includes a fully sheared closure member or tab 70, similar to the tab 20 of Figure 3, hinged to the end at 71. The tab 70 has a pressure releasing closure member or tab 72 defined by lines of severance 73 and 74 extending to either side of a raised button 75. The lines 73 and 74 have an included angle of about 60° although it has been found that the tab 72 will operate successfully with the lines 73 and 74 at any included angle within the range of about 30° to 180°, and most successfully between 50° and 70°.
The tab 72 flexes about its connection 76 to the tab 70 in the same basic manner as the embodiment of Figures 3 and 4 although it will be noted that the angular nature of the lines of severance 73 and 74 positions the connection 76 more remotely from the raised button 75 than in the case of the embodiment of Figures 3 and 4.
For the tab dimensions and button height shown in the drawings, the tab 72 is incapable, in normal operation, of being opened by means of a digitally applied force beyond about 3° to 5°. This angle range is below the angle at which the metal at the connection 76 will be permanently deformed so that the tab 72 will in normal use always return to a substantially closed position once the opening force is removed.
The tab 70 is formed within a depressed area 77 which is formed in the same basic manner as described above in relation to Figures 9 to 12. However, the method of formation of the pressure releasing tab 72 is modified to form the lines of severance 73 and 74. The lines of severance 73 and 74 are formed by a stepped punch during an initial stage in the shearing of the tab 70. In the same initial operation, the remainder of the tab 72 is also sheared and as the punch progresses downwardly, the sides of the tab 70 are reformed downwardly and the tab 70 severed as described in connection with Figure 12. The free edges of the two tabs 70 and 72 are then brought together so that the two tabs are coplanar at the periphery of the tab. The formation of the lines of severance and the downwardly reformed nature of the sides of the tab 70 leaves a step of one material thickness between the tabs 70 and 72 along the inner portions of the lines of severance 73 and 74.
The tabs 70 and 72 are coined near their free edges to increase the overlap between them and the surrounding metal. The coin is preferably interrupted at the lines of severance 73 and 74 to ensure free opening thereof during the flexing of the tab 72 about the connection 76.
If desired, the depressed area 77 may be formed in a flat end panel, as shown in the sectional view of Figure 16, to achieve the same degree of protection without doming the end panel. Similarly, the closure construction shown in Figures 3 and 4 may be formed by the above method rather than the method described in connection with this embodiment or vice versa. However, the avoidance of moving punch components is preferred.
It will be appreciated that the positioning of the pressure releasing opening and tab radially inwardly of the pouring opening and tab, at or near the centre of the end, as shown in Figures 3, 6, 7 and 14, offers the advantage that the pressure releasing tab is located at the best possible position to reduce the likelihood of the level of the liquid being above the pressure releasing closure.
It will also be noted that in each of the above embodiments, the pressure releasing tab and opening is considerably smaller than the venting tab of the prior art ends and this results in the tab being significantly easier to open than the prior art tabs. The tab V in the prior art end must operate both as a pressure venting tab and an air venting opening and for this reason the tab must either be large enough and/or be raised to such an extent as to be capable of being permanently opened sufficiently to perform the second function. It will be understood that if the tab is small it must be raised further to allow access and if the tab is too small then there will be insufficient metal available to raise it to the extent necessary. However, since the tab in the present invention functions only to release pressure, it is not necessary or desirable to raise it enough to be manually depressed to a position in which it vents the can during pouring since this is achieved, in the second and third embodiments, when the pouring tab is opened. It should be appreciated however that the pressure releasing tab need not be smaller than the tab V in order for the advantages of the invention to be attained.
The configurations of the openings shown in the various Figures 3, 6, 7 and 14 are not essential and may be modified without affecting the performance of the closure as described above. It is envisaged that the sides of the pear-shaped opening 21 may be slightly curved outwardly to give the opening a more appealing appearance. Similarly the pressure releasing tab 28 may be used in place of the tab 11 shown in Figure 2 or may be formed in a closure or any other suitable configuration.
While each of the above embodiments includes fully sheared tabs, the invention is equally applicable to closures defined by score lines or other forms of weakening lines, such as disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 3,334,775.
The closures of the present invention can be used in can ends or in other container members, and can be formed of any suitable sheet metal material, including aluminum and steel, and can be of any suitable shape, depending upon the shape of the can body to which the can end or other container member is to be secured. It is also envisaged that the closures may be made in plastics materials by suitable moulding techniques.
There is no criticality in the absolute size of the pouring closure, although normally the pouring closure will be of such size as to prevent complete insertion of a user's finger, yet large enough to permit adequate outflow of liquid container contents. Likewise, the absolute size of the pressure releasing/venting aperture or opening is not critical, but normally the opening will be of a size as to prevent complete insertion of a user's finger, yet large enough to permit adequate outflow of internal container pressure upon pressure releasing, and to permit adequate inflow of air upon venting.
The sealant which is used for fully severed closures can be any suitable means or material, such as a sealing compound, plastic tape, adhesive foil, hot melt material, or a combination thereof. A particularly suitable sealing compound is a plastisol-grade polyvinylchloride combined with a conventional plastisizer and compounding ingredients. Such plastisol should be heat curable to form a non-tacky, somewhat yieldable solid material that aids in retaining the closure in place and maintains a hermetic seal under pressures of the magnitudes which normally occur in cans of carbonated and malt beverages. The sealant must be sufficiently frangible to be ruptured upon the application of digitally applied push-in force on the respective closures. The maximum angular displacements of the closure mentioned above apply only to the indicated grade of aluminum, and to the indicated thickness thereof. Changes of these and other variables in the closure construction will change the maximum permissible angle of displacement.

Claims

1. A push-in pressure releasing closure in a container member suitable for liquids under pressure, comprising a closure member formed integrally from a portion of the container member and defined by at least a weakening line and being of dimensions capable of being opened by a digitally applied push-in force against the action of said pressure, said closure member having an operating portion which is adapted in use to have said push-in force applied thereto and a connection to said container member, characterised in that means are provided for substantially preventing permanent opening of said closure member by an unrestrained digitally applied push-in force whereby said closure member substantially returns to its closed position in the absence of said digitally applied push-in force to such an extent as to inhibit the escape of froth and/or liquid under pressure from within said container member.

2. The closure of claim 1, characterised in that said closure member is constructed to prevent deflection of said closure member by said digitally applied push-in force beyond the angle at which the elastic limit of the metal at said connection is exceeded.

3. The closure of claim 1, characterised in that said operating portion is raised relative to the surrounding portion of the container member, the extent to which said operating portion is raised and/or the effective size of said operating portion available for said digitally applied push-in force being selected such that under normal circumstances of use the digitally applied force is unable to deflect the closure member about said connection beyond the angle at which the elastic limit of the metal forming said connection is exceeded whereby application of said opening force does not permanently open the closure at least while said closure member is subjected to the pressure within said container member.

4. The closure of claim 2 or 3, characterised in that said operating portion and said connection are spaced sufficiently from each other to prevent deflection beyond said angle.

5. The closure of claim 3, characterised in that said container member is formed with a pouring closure member defined by at least a weakening line, said pouring closure having a narrow end and a wide end, said pressure releasing closure member being formed as part of said pouring closure member and located at said narrow end thereof, said connection being defined by a narrow neck of metal between two lines which are at least weakened so as to be severed by said push-in force and which extend towards each other from opposite edges of the pouring closure member.

6. The closure of claim 5, characterised in that said pouring closure member is fully sheared from said container member except for a neck of metal which acts as a hinge for the pouring closure member during the opening operation thereof, said two lines being lines of severance formed in said pouring closure member.

7. The closure of claim 6, characterised in that said pouring closure member is in overlapping underlying relationship with the surrounding portions of said container member, the metal on either side of said lines of severance being in substantially the same plane.

8. The closure of claim 7, characterised in that said container member is a can end, said narrow end of said pouring closure member being formed adjacent the centre of the end.

9. The closure of claim 3, characterised in that said container member is formed with a pouring closure member defined by at least a weakening line, said pouring closure having a narrow end and a wide end, said pressure releasing closure.member being formed as part of said pouring closure member and located at said narrow end thereof, said connection being defined by narrow necks of metal adjacent opposite edges of said pouring closure and a line which is at least weakened so as to be severed by said push-in force, said line extending generally transversely of the pouring closure.

10. The closure of claim 9, characterised in that said line is a line of severance formed in said closure.

11. The closure of claim 4, characterised in the provision of a pouring closure member formed in said container member, said pressure releasing closure member being formed as an integral extension of said pouring closure member, said pressure releasing closure member being removed from its closing position when said pouring closure member is opened whereby an air venting opening is provided for the pouring operation.

12. The closure of claim 11, characterised in that said pouring closure member is fully sheared from said container member except for a neck of metal which acts as a hinge for the pouring closure member during the opening operation thereof.

13. The closure of claim 4, characterised in that said pressure releasing closure member is fully sheared from said container member, said operating portion being disposed at one end of a narrow elongate portion extending to said connection, said operating portion being in overlapping underlying relationship with the surrounding portions of the container member.

14. The closure of claim 13, characterised in that said pressure releasing closure member is formed within a larger closure which may act as a pouring closure member.

15. A can end for a container suitable for liquids under pressure, including a liquid pouring closure and a pressure releasing closure in said end to be opened by a digitally applied push-in force characterised in that said pressure releasing closure co-operates with the portion of the can end surrounding said pressure releasing closure to physically limit the unrestrained depression of said pressure releasing closure by said digitally applied push-in force to cause said pressure releasing closure to return substantially to its closed position in the absence of said digitally applied push-in force to such an extent as to inhibit the escape of froth and/or liquid under pressure from within said container.

16. The can end of claim 15, characterised in that said pressure releasing closure member is attached to said can end by an integral connection and is constructed to prevent deflection of said closure member by said digitally applied push-in force beyond the angle at which the elastic limit of the metal at said connection is exceeded.