WO2009152494A1

WO2009152494A1 - Hybrid power facilities

Info

Publication number: WO2009152494A1
Application number: PCT/US2009/047343
Authority: WO
Inventors: Roger Ferguson; Kenneth Bryden; Steven Corns; Luke Shors
Original assignee: Roger Ferguson; Kenneth Bryden; Steven Corns; Luke Shors
Priority date: 2008-06-13
Filing date: 2009-06-15
Publication date: 2009-12-17
Also published as: WO2009152496A1

Abstract

A hybrid power plant is disclosed wherein a first power plant produces secondary steam of a first, relatively low temperature using a renewable source of energy such as geothermal or solar. The steam from the renewable source plant is passed through a fossil fuel power plant that has an operating temperature higher than that of the first temperature which results in superheating the first temperature steam to the higher temperature in the fossil fuel power plant. Higher efficiencies and reductions in emissions are obtained.

Description

HYBRID POWER FACILITIES

Cross-reference to Related Applications

[0001] This application claims priority to United States Patent Application Serial No. 61/061,189, filed June 13, 2008, which is incorporated herein by this reference, and is a continuation-in-part of United States Patent Application Serial No. 12/394,272, filed February 27, 2009.

Background of the Invention

[0002] The invention relates generally to power plants and, more specifically, to hybrid power facilities combining combustion power plants and solar or geothermal facilities. This patent addresses power plant technologies used in coal fired power plants. These technologies can make use of either coal or biomass (bulk or pelletized) as a fuel source, and so they are generically referred to as 'coal' in this work.

[0003] The initial step in this project was a literature review to investigate similar work that has been examined in the area and thereby establish the originality of this proposal. This literature review was composed of two areas: similar patents and scholarly papers in the area. While generating capacity exists for geothermal and solar energy systems, they are currently viewed as an emerging technology by the industry, and so there is limited information in industry publications describing existing designs and most documentation is found in scholarly journals.

[0004] There are several scholarly articles regarding hybrid power systems involving solar and/or geothermal energy. Some examples of these combinations are as follows: (a) Solar and Geothermal (Lentz and Almanza, 2006) - This paper describes a hot dry rock geothermal power plant that is augmented using a solar field of parabolic troughs concentrators; (b) DiPippo, Kestin, and Khalifa (1978 and 1981) - These works describe the use of fossil fuels to add superheat to steam created from geothermal sources. While binary geothermal systems were not addressed, it was noted by the authors that the efficiency of geothermal systems was greatly improved through the use of coal powered superheaters; and (c) Bruhn (1999) - This paper describes the use of geothermal energy to add preheat to a fossil fuel powered steam turbine cycle. This was found to be beneficial in low energy geothermal fields, but this same benefit could be achieved using standard feed water heaters. [0005] While there are several existing designs that combine different elements of renewable energy with fossil-fuel technology, the use of coal and the associated advances in coal furnace technology have not been addressed with either geothermal or solar power facilities. This indicates that the combination of these renewable energy streams with traditional coal-fired technology is unique. The work that has been published to date can be grouped into two categories: 1) methods for using fossil fuel fired furnace to add energy to steam produced from renewable energy streams, and 2) combined cycles using gas turbine units and renewable energy power plants.

[0006] The present design fits into the first group, as it uses a fossil fuel device to superheat steam created using renewable sources of energy. In these proposed hybrid plants, energy from a renewable source is used to preheat and/or boil the feed water while using the energy from a coal fired furnace to add superheat to the steam and preheat the feedwater. This design makes use of the benefits of a full scale coal fired furnace to utilize as much of the combustion heat as possible with the latent heat for producing the steam supplied by the renewable energy side of the hybrid plant.

[0007] Other designs falling in the general area of superheating steam produced from renewable sources are as follows:

[0008] Blaize [1994] filed for a patent for a design that routed the saturated steam from a hot, dry rock geothermal power plant through a superheater which was fueled by "natural gas, ethanol, or other clean-burning fuel." This solution differs in that it requires a high energy reservoir of geothermal energy and specifically uses gaseous or liquid fuels rather than coal or biomass. Most importantly, this patent describes only a fossil-fuel burner that adds superheat, making no use of the hot exhaust gases from combustion to either preheat the working fluids or the combustion air.

[0009] Broadus [1995] filed a patent for a design that routed the steam from a hot, dry rock geothermal power plant through a gas turbine, increasing the amount of mass expanding in the turbine and increasing the power output. While this increases the power output, it is also very likely that fouling of the gas turbine blades will occur, making the gas turbine unusable. It is significantly different from our design.

[0010] A design by Moore [1995] was patented that uses the thermal energy from a solar central receiver to heat molten salt. This salt is then passed through a furnace, where it is heated with either the exhaust of a gas turbine unit or by fossil fuel fired burners. This salt is then used to generate superheated steam to drive a steam turbine generator. While this design does incorporate several conventional coal power plant technologies such as feed water heaters, it differs from our design in that the fossil fuel adds heat to a working fluid other than the steam. Also, it specifies "fluid" fuels, such as natural gas or fuel oil as opposed to our design using coal.

[0011] There are several other patents describing the use of the exhaust steam of a gas turbine to add energy to steam produced from solar sources or solar energy to preheat the air entering a gas turbine. These include Finckh [1981], Bharathan [1995], and Goldman [2007]. The most notable of these is a patent held by Cohn [1998], which also employs a reheater and a feed water heater. All of these designs use gaseous fuels other than coal or biomass to add heat to the vapor power cycle they are driving, and so a distinctly different from our design. [0012] DiPippo, Kestin, and Khalifa [1978 and 1981], performed a large amount of analysis on the combination of fossil fuel energy and geothermal energy. Similar research was also conducted by Bruhn [1999]. DiPippo et al. concentrated on flash steam units and did not address problems with that working fluid, and Bruhn only analyzed the use of geothermal energy as a preheat. Also, neither examined the available methods for increasing performance in a conventional power plant, only listed the efficiencies that could be gained when these were used.

[0013] Other patents and research in this area are a combined cycle geothermal and fuel cell system described in the patent by Licari et al. [2006], which uses a combined cycle system with a fuel cell producing electricity and the waste heat of the fuel cell used in conjunction with a geothermal plant to increase the cycle efficiency. This is fundamentally different than our design. Also, hybrid solar energy receivers as described in a patent by Mehos [2004] are namely hybrid solar receiver which can also utilize fossil fuel to increase the thermal output. This unit is mounted on a parabolic mirror, and can only be used for a sterling engine.

Summary of the Invention

[0014] The invention consists of a hybrid power plant that combines a variety of renewable heat sources with a fossil fuel furnace system. Saturated steam would be generated by the renewable sources and then superheat would be added to the steam by the fossil fuel fired furnace. These renewable sources would include geothermal and thermal solar energy sources.

Brief Description of the Drawings

[0015] Fig. 1 is a schematic diagram of a hybrid geothermal-fossil fuel power plant. [0016] Fig. 2 is a schematic diagram of a hybrid parabolic trough-fossil fuel power plant.

Description of the Invention

[0017] This is the initial report on the proposed design of a hybrid power plant that combines renewable heat sources with a fossil fuel furnace system. Saturated steam would be generated by the renewable sources and then superheat would be added to the steam by the fossil fuel fired furnace. These renewable sources would include geothermal and thermal solar energy sources. A brief discussion of how these energy sources are utilized will be helpful when considering how to combine these energy sources with other existing methods.

Geothermal

[0018] There are three forms of geothermal energy that could potentially be used in combination with other methods of energy production: (1) Hydrothermal - Steam generated in the Earth's crust; (2) Hot Dry Rock - Heated rock formations in the Earth's crust; and (3) Magma - Magmatic intrusions near the Earth's surface.

[0019] Currently, the majority of the geothermal energy being used to produce electricity is from the hydrothermal resources. This is done by tapping into existing steam/hot water contained in reservoirs in the rock. Hot dry rock resources are nearly identical except that there is no water trapped underground. Both of these methods are currently employed in the generation of electricity, although the requirements for hydrothermal limit the locations where it can be used. Magma energy takes advantage of molten rock located near the Earth's surface to create electricity.

[0020] Of these three technologies, hydrothermal and hot dry rock are the only methods practiced at this time. Drilling at the only proposed magma energy site was initiated in 1989 to test experimental apparatus for use in magma energy, but high costs and difficulty in reaching the required depths has prevented this test equipment from being implemented. Hydrothermal has the most installed capacity, with approximately 2GW of electricity being generated from a Northern California site (The Geysers).

[0021] There are three methods for extracting energy from geothermal sources: dry steam systems, flash systems, and binary cycles. Dry steam systems operate by extracting underground steam and routing it through a steam turbine to generate electricity. The steam is then condensed and pumped back into the Earth through reinjection wells. This method requires the least amount of capital equipment, but also requires a geothermal source of steam, requiring a high concentration of geothermal energy. Most accessible sources of geothermal energy are lower energy sites (most hydrothermal and essentially all hot dry rock) that provide heated water rather than steam. To produce electrical energy from these sources requires that steam be produced through another mechanism. For the flash type system, the hot working fluid is passed into a lower pressure flash chamber, where the decreased pressure causes some of the hot water to flash to steam. This steam can then be used to drive a turbine, as in the dry steam system. Another method is to transfer the heat of the working fluid into a secondary fluid in a binary system. This type of system uses the hot geothermal fluid to boil a second working fluid that is then used to produce electricity. Using a closed system for the vapor power system makes it possible to use a working fluid with a lower flash point. This makes it possible to generate pressurized steam at much lower temperatures than if water were used. [0022] Two of the main issues associated with geothermal power are the low operating temperature and the chemistry of the working fluids. The operating temperature for geothermal plants is dictated by the temperature of the rock formations that are providing the thermal energy. The hydrothermal plants rely on pre-existing steam flows to provide this energy, and so there is no investment necessary to supply the working fluid. Because of this, the steam temperature is limited to what occurs in nature, with a typical value of about 400⁰F, although some sources give values as high as 600⁰F. While there are many more locations where hot dry rock geothermal energy could be produced, these locations are limited by current technology' s ability to penetrate the Earth's crust and to maintain clear and usable geothermal wells. These limitations prevent reliable access to thermal reservoirs buried deep in the Earth, making 35O⁰F a typical expected temperature from this resource.

[0023] Another issue with geothermal energy sources is the mineral content that the working fluid picks up as it is heated. Because the water is pumped underground and then collected to use the thermal energy, a large amount of minerals are absorbed into the fluid. This often leads to heavy fouling (a buildup of deposits that reduces heat transfer) of the power plant surfaces where the energy is transferred. There is also a possibility that the working fluid will become caustic, which reduces the power plant's life span and can be hazardous to operators.

Solar

[0024] There are three forms of solar energy that could potentially be used in combination with other methods of energy production: (1) Central Receivers - Solar radiation concentrated on a receiving tower using mirrors (Heliostats); (2) Parabolic Troughs - Reflective troughs that concentrate solar energy on a pipe running through the focal point; and (3) Photovoltaics - Directly converts solar radiation to electricity on an atomic scale.

[0025] Other forms of solar energy are the parabolic dish and solar ponds. Parabolic dishes are similar to parabolic troughs, except that the energy is focused to a single point. This energy can be sufficient to operate a sterling engine, but currently there is no evident technology that can bring this technology to a large enough scale to be considered for use in a utility application. The temperatures achieved in a solar pond are typically 200F or lower, making the use of this technology impractical for large scale power production. [0026] Photovoltaics are the most well known method to produce electricity from solar energy, however the cost to produce the solar cells, the hazardous waste stream that they produce when manufactured and low efficiency prohibits their use in commercial scale energy production.

[0027] Central receiver systems collect solar energy by using a field of heliostats to concentrate the energy on a tower placed in the center of the heliostat field. This concentration of energy is used to heat a molten salt in the tower, which is then circulated through a heat exchanger to boil a working fluid to drive a Rankine cycle. Typical values for these central receivers can be as high as HOO⁰F, yielding steam temperatures as high as 1050⁰F. However, no central receiver system has been constructed that has more than 15MW of capacity. [0028] Parabolic trough systems collect solar energy by reflecting and concentrating the sunlight on a pipe running through the centerline of the parabolic solar collectors. This concentrated sunlight heats oil that is being pumped through the pipe to a temperature as high as 735⁰F. This oil can then be used in a heat exchanger to boil water and add superheat to the steam produced.

[0029] While the thermal solar energy systems can achieve temperatures sufficient to drive high efficiency energy cycles, size limitations constrain the amount of energy that can be gathered at one site. Central receiver systems have been able to achieve steam temperatures comparable to those found in some smaller coal-fired power plants (at a much lower steam flow rate), but require a large footprint to produce a relatively small amount of energy. In addition, the heat transfer fluids used in these systems (molten salt, thermal oils, etc.) are either solids or very thick liquids at normal atmospheric temperatures. To keep these fluids in a usable state during shutdown periods or large transients requires an addition of heat, usually from fossil fuel powered sources.

Novel hybrid power plants

Superheated Steam from Hybrid Power Facilities:

[0030] The primary focus of this research is to establish the viability of merging energy sources to increase the overall utility of both. This utility includes the cost of both fuel and facilities as well as overall plant efficiency and emission controls. While there are existing patents that are similar to our concepts, there are several novel design combinations proposed here that are advantageous: (a) Geothermal (hydro thermal and dry, hot rock) saturated steam with fossil-fuel superheater. This could be from direct steam, flash type steam generators or binary systems and (b) solar energy system for saturated steam with fossil-fuel superheater.

Geothermal-Fossil Fuel Hybrid Plant:

[0031] This patent combines a full scale fossil fuel furnace with a geothermal plant (Fig. 1). Steam is generated from any of the three types of geothermal sources; direct steam, flash steam or a boiler for binary geothermal systems. The steam produced by these methods is saturated steam, mainly due to the low thermal energy levels found in geothermal sources. This saturated steam is then passed through a superheater of a coal fired furnace where the steam is superheated by energy released from the coal combustion. The superheated steam is then passed through the turbine train. In the case of hydrothermal power plants, the steam could then be released to atmosphere or allowed to condense to supply water for any local needs. For hot, dry rock systems the steam would be condensed in the condenser and then pump back into the earth to absorb more energy. It would also be possible to pass the condensed fluid through an economizer to reduce the risk of depleting the energy in the geothermal well. [0032] This design uses the energy from the geothermal source to boil the water and the energy from the combustion of coal or biomass to add superheat to the steam and preheat the feedwater. This takes advantage of the higher operating temperature of the combustion to superheat the steam, making it possible to use a superheated steam turbine train. By using a turbine train designed for higher temperature steam, a higher efficiency can be achieved. The coal fired furnace in this design includes devices that does not boil the working fluid but adds superheat and also the use of the superheater section of a separate fossil fuel power plant that is operating to produce a separate steam flow.

Solar-Fossil Fuel Hybrid Plant

[0033] This patent combines a full scale fossil fuel furnace with a solar plant. We use a parabolic trough facility as our example (Fig. 2), but any form of solar energy to produce steam at a lower energy than the combustion system would be applicable. Solar energy is collected directed to a heat exchanger, where the secondary working fluid is boiled to produce steam. This steam is then passed through a combustion furnace where the steam is superheated by energy released from the coal or biomass combustion. The superheated steam is then passed through the turbine train, condensed in the condenser and enters the feed pumps. The feed pumps move the fluid through the economizer of the furnace and then route it back to the heat exchanger.

[0034] This design uses the energy from the solar system to boil the water and add superheat when possible, with the remaining superheat added by the energy from the combustion of coal or biomass. The remainder of the combustion energy is then used to preheat the feed water. This takes advantage of the higher operating temperature of the combustion to superheat the steam, making it possible to use a higher temperature steam turbine train. By using a turbine train designed for higher temperature steam, a higher efficiency can be achieved. The coal fired furnace in this design includes devices that do not boil the working fluid but adds superheat and also the use of the superheater section of a separate fossil fuel power plant that is operating to produce a separate steam flow. Evaluation

[0035] The combinations of technologies in each of these proposed solutions create a facility that is advantageous to the stand alone technologies. Of the technologies discussed here, only coal is widely agreed to be a contributor of greenhouse gases. The following discusses some of the benefits found in the given combinations using example cases.

[0036] The combination of geothermal power and other technologies has a varying benefit depending mainly on the availability of geothermal power. This is due in large part because of the varying reports on the amount of geothermal energy available at a given source. For the analysis in this report, the assumption will be that a temperature of 600⁰F can be reached using geothermal reservoirs. This allows for a large contribution from the geothermal source. Smaller geothermal energy sources would gain as much or more of a benefit from our design by the addition of more energy to the system.

Geothermal-Fossil Fuel Hybrid Plant

[0037] In this model, the geothermal energy is used to create steam from feed water and add some superheat (contributing 1118 Btu/lbm of working fluid), while coal is used to add the remaining superheat (contributing 447 Btu/lbm) This results in an electricity cost of roughly $0,069 per kW-hr, with a carbon emission reduction of 71% when compared to a comparable coal powered facility. In addition, by combining a coal facility to an existing geothermal plant, the plant capacity (in MWe) is increased by about 70%. (ie. A IOOMW geothermal power plant would produce 170 MW when combined with a coal-fired power plant.)

Parabolic Trough-Fossil Fuel Hybrid Plant

[0038] This design uses the energy collected from a parabolic trough field to boil and slightly superheat water (contributing 1220 Btu/lbm) and then adds the remaining amount of superheat using coal (contributing 346 Btu/lbm.) This yields an electricity cost of about $0.09 lper kW-hr and a carbon reduction of nearly 78%. The combination of the coal plant to the parabolic trough facility gives an increase in plant capacity of about 51%.

How Energy is Combined [0039] For the previous descriptions, the systems were maintained as two distinctly different systems that act on the secondary working fluid (steam). It would also be possible to combine these technologies to act on the primary working fluid. For geothermal technologies, the hot ground water could be heated directly in a coal burning furnace provided it was adequately pressurized to prevent it from flashing to steam.

Capacity

[0040] The increased capacity of these power plants is important, in that most of the installed capacity is of a much smaller scale than traditional coal power plants. For the solar installations, this extra energy could be used to heat molten salt in a storage facility so that the plant could continue to produce electricity when there is no sun. This would remove one of the larger drawbacks to solar energy; it is only available when there is sunlight. [0041] When applied to the geothermal power plants, there is a concern as to whether the geothermal reservoirs are truly renewable energy sources. Some fields have been "overworked" by removing too much energy, and it is theorized that these fields will be usable once energy has been allowed to build back up. By maintaining the initial capacity while removing less heat from the geothermal reservoir, we argue that we can make this a more renewable resource by not overworking and therefore depleting the wells.

Materials

[0042] One of the comments made by previous patent holders was a concern regarding the availability of materials necessary to construct a full scale fossil fuel furnace that would only add superheat to the steam. While these materials may now exist, there are several other options that would maintain a lower temperature in the furnace, making these more expensive materials unnecessary.

[0043] There are two techniques that could be applied using a coal fired furnace to maintain a lower temperature. One would be to combust the coal in a lower oxygen environment, slowing the rate of reaction and preventing a higher temperature from being achieved. Another option would be to utilize a fluidized bed furnace, which typically operate at lower temperatures than a pulverized coal or chain grate type boiler. In addition, the use of a fluidized bed furnace provides an opportunity to reduce the sulfur dioxide emissions from the power plant and makes it possible to burn a wider variety of fuels.

[0044] Biomass fuels have a lower flame temperature than coal, and so operating temperatures would also be lower. This would not only make it possible to have a higher efficiency power plant by utilizing superheated steam, it may also be possible to reduce the net carbon emissions of the plant to zero. This in turn would make more carbon credits available and increase the profit potential of the design.

Maintaining Solar Coolants:

[0045] One of the issues to be addressed in the use of solar energy is the amount of energy that needs to be maintained in the system to ensure that the primary heat transfer fluid remains in a usable state. By connecting a solar system to a fossil fuel fired furnace the heat from the fossil fuel energy source could be used to maintain the temperature levels necessary to prevent solidification of the molten salt for the central receiver or congealing of the thermal oils in the parabolic trough systems.

References

Bellac, A. and Destefanis, R. (2005) "Solar Power Enhanced Combustion Turbine Power Plants and Methods," US Patent 6,941,759.

Bharathan, D., Bohn, M., and Williams, T. (1995) "Hybrid Solar Central Receiver for

Combined Cycle Power Plant," US Patent 5,417,052.

Blaize, L. (1994) "Hybrid Electric Power Generation," US Patent 5,311,741.

Broadus, J. (1995) "Combined Geothermal and Fossil Fuel Power Plant," US Patent 5,442,906.

Bruhn, M. (1999) "Hybrid geothermal-fossil electricity generation from low enthalpy geothermal resources: geothermal feedwater preheating in conventional power plants," Energy,

Volume 27, pp. 329-346.

Cohn, A. (1998) "Hybrid Solar and Fuel Fired Electrical Generating System," US Patent

5,727,379.

Cohn, A. (1999) "Hybrid Solar and Fuel Fired Electrical Generating System," US Patent

5,857,322.

DiPippio, R., Khalifa, H. E., Correia, R., and Kestin, J. (1978) "Fossil Superheating in

Geothermal Steam Power Plants," Department of Energy Report, Contract No. Ey-76-S-02-

4051. AOOl.

DiPippio, R., DiPippio, E. A., Kestin, J., and Khalifa, H.E. (1981) "Compound Hybrid

Geothermal-Fossil Power Plants," Journal of Engineering for Power, 103(4), pp. 797-804.

El-Wakil, M. M. (1984) Powerplant Technology, McGraw-Hill Inc., New York, NY.

Finckh, H. (1981) "Solar Power Plant with Open Gas Turbine Circuit," US Patent 4,259,836.

Fisher, U. (2003) "Method and Apparatus for Producing Power," US Patent 6,510,695.

Goldman, A. (2007) "Hybrid Generation with Alternative Fuel Sources," US Patent

Application, Pub. No. US 2007/0012041 Al.

Lentz, A. and Almanza, R. (2005) "Solar-geothermal hybrid system," Applied Thermal

Engineering, 26, pp. 1537-1544.

Licari, J., Ottesen, H., and Walters, J. (2006) "Hybrid Geothermal and Fuel-Cell System," US

Patent Application, Pub. No. US 2006/0053794 Al.

Mehos, M., Anselmo, K., Moreno, J., Andraka, C, Rawlinson, K., Coreyu, J., and Bohn, M.

(2004) "Combustion System for Hybrid Solar Fossil Fuel Receiver," US Patent 6,739,136 B2. Meksvanh, S., Whelan, R., and Swift, D. (2006) "Solar Augmented Geothermal Energy," US

Patent Application, Pub. No. US 2006/0048770 Al.

Moore, R. (1995) "Solar-Gas Combined Cycle Electrical Generation System," US Patent

5,444,972.

Stultz, S. C. & Kitton, J. B. (Eds.) (1992) Steam/its generation and use, 40th edition, The

Babcock and Wilcox Company, Barberton, OH.

Claims

We claim:

1. A hybrid power plant, comprising:

(a) a first power plant which produces secondary steam of a first temperature using a renewable source of energy;

(b) a fossil fuel power plant that has an operating temperature higher than that of the first temperature; and

(c) superheating the first temperature steam to the higher temperature in the fossil fuel power plant.

2. A hybrid power plant as defined in claim 1, wherein the first power plant is selected from the list consisting of geothermal and solar power plants.

3. A hybrid power plant as defined in claim 2, wherein the fossil fuel power plant is selected from the list consisting of coal -, oil -, petroleum -, natural gas -, propane -, and hydrogen- fueled power plants.