METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR PRESERVING FOOD
TECHNICAL FIELD
The present invention relates to a method for preparation of shelf stable food, particularly meat, vegetables, fruits and products based on meat, vegetables and fruit. More particularly, the present invention relates to a method for resisting or preventing the degradation of food, particularly food stored at ambient temperature over extended periods of time of up to two years or more. Even more particularly the present invention relates to a method for decreasing the viability of undesirable microorganisms and enzymes associated with food to provide an improved shelf stable product, in many cases produced at much lower temperatures and with much reduced periods of heating than many other shelf stabilisation processes resulting in a more organoleptically acceptable product.
Although the present invention will be described with particular reference to the preparation of shelf stable meat, vegetable and fruit and products based on these food groups, it will be readily appreciated by the persons skilled in the relevant technology that the scope of the present invention is not limited to meat, vegetable and fruit and products based on these food groups but rather the scope is more extensive to include food generally, including home replacement meals comprising meats and vegetables, bulk food service portions, unprocessed food such as nuts and pulses, and processed foods such as salamis, cheeses, bread, pastries and the like. The scope of the present
invention also extends to preservation of food for short term as well as long term storage.
The method and apparatus of the invention is not limited to the described arrangement or embodiment but rather the scope is more extensive so as to include other arrangements of the apparatus and applications other than those specifically described.
BACKGROUND ART
Food preservation methods applied to prevent or delay the deterioration of food have been used for centuries . Early hunter-gatherers prepared dried meats such as pemmican and used caves and other cool places to provide refrigeration of their food. Cheese and yoghurt are the products of fermentation, a food preservation technique known from early times. Fruits, vegetables and meat have been preserved by pickling, a process in which food is salted to selectively control microorganisms such as bacteria then fermented to stabilise the treated tissues. Preservation of fruit has also been practiced for centuries by concentrating soluble solids as jams, marmalades and other preserves. The natural and/or added sugar in these foods also acts as a preservative.
Early efforts at food preservation were often effective at delaying food deterioration, but the texture and colour of the food often suffered and the food was often either tasteless or alternatively comprised an overwhelming taste of salts or spices used to preserve the food. The development by Pasteur in
1846 of the food sterilization process now known as pasteurisation was a significant step forward in food processing technology. The rise of the consumer society and advances in food processing technology have radically improved all aspects of food preservation during the twentieth century. Methods of food preservation based on the pasteurisation process such as canning, freeze-drying and irradiation have made enormous progress . Vast numbers of chemicals are also now used in food preservation not only to preserve the food but to improve the colour, taste and texture.
Consumer expectations of preserved foods have risen to a very high level . Consumers quite reasonably expect that they can eat a preserved food at any time before its "use by" or "best before" date without running the risk of infection and sickness caused by harmful microorganisms including certain bacteria, spores, fungi and enzymes. Consumers also expect that preserved food will remain unspoiled and not change in appearance, at least until the "use by date" is reached.
The "use by date" is usually displayed on a the packaging of preserved foods and indicates the date until which the foodstuff should not start to exhibit any significant decrease in quality. Foods which have a use by date at least 2 years after their date of manufacture are referred to as "shelf stable". Shelf stable products are not only in demand from ordinary consumers but are also used as part of army rations, campers' supplies, rescue and relief packages and so forth.
In recent times, consumers have also become very aware of potential health risks associated with the use of unacceptable chemical additives and certain methods of preservation such as irradiation.
Accordingly one of the most popular methods of preservation of food is pasteurisation or sterilization using retort technology because this method does not generally require the use of additives such as chemicals or techniques such as irradiation. Retort technology is based on sterilization of food using heat, for example by heating a product to destroy vegetative cells of various forms of microorganisms such as bacteria that cause spoilage. This form of sterilization can be used with many food products, particularly those with a pH below 4.5, to retard bacterial spoilage.
A typical process for preserving food using retort technology may comprise placing sealed packages of food in a retort and then pressurising the retort while the food packages are submerged in hot water for a period of time sufficient to raise the internal temperature of the food to a predetermined level. In another typical process for preserving food using retort technology, packaged foods traveling on a conveyer belt are sprayed from above and below with heated water until the internal temperature of the food rises to a predetermined level .
One of the problems associated with this type of food preservation is that application of heat for a minimum amount of time suitable to kill bacteria may cause changes in the food that detract from its
appearance. For example, sweet corn or maize has a relatively high natural sugar content, and the application of heat during sterilisation by retort technology tends to caramelise the sugar, thus altering the corn from its natural yellow colour to a caramel colour. Consumers prefer preserved food to have the same appearance as the corresponding fresh food and often associate such a colour change with poor quality.
This problem has been recognized for canned foods, which are often subjected to relatively high temperatures for long periods of time in order to kill microorganisms such as Clostridium Jotulinuzn which only produces its lethal toxin when it has achieved the vegetative form growing under anaerobic conditions.
Thus, in US patent number 4,741,911 there is described a process for canning vegetables in which the vegetables are irst blanched in water, then placed in a can and a salt solution including a mixture of an aldonic acid with its lactones is added to the can to cover the vegetables. The can is then sealed and subjected to the usual sterilization process. In this process it is found that the amount of heat necessary to sterilize the vegetables is substantially less than the amount required without the addition of the mixture of an aldonic acid and its lactones to the salt solution contained in the can.
It will be appreciated that when it comes time to consume the canned vegetables, the can is opened and the vegetables are separated from the liquid contents of the can prior to consumption. Hence, the process has limited applicability to other types of food and is
certainly not applicable to those foods which are not stored in a liquid medium. Moreover, it does not lend itself to packaging of foods in other ways such as in clear plastic bags or trays wherein foods appear to be freshly packed with no liquids present other than natural juices .
It has now been found that the preservation of foodstuffs can be greatly improved by a simple method of pre-processing carried out before the main food preservation process such as pasteurisation or sterilisation by retort technology.
DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION
According to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided a method for pre-processing food prior to a main food preservation process, comprising subjecting the food to a treatment which serves to decrease the viability of any microorganisms in the food.
In one embodiment of the invention, the treatment which serves to decrease the viability of any microorganisms in the food comprises blanching the food with an acidic solution.
In an alternative embodiment of the invention, the treatment which serves to decrease the viability of any microorganisms comprises mixing an acid into the food.
According to a second aspect of the present
invention there is provided a method of preserving food, comprising the steps of:
(1) subjecting the food to a treatment which serves to decrease the viability of any microorganisms in the food; and
(2) subjecting the food to heat in a food preservation process.
Typically, the food preservation process is pasteurization or sterilization by retort technology.
In general, the pre-processed food is sealed in packaging and the packaged pre-processed food in a heated environment (for example, filled with steam and/or hot water depending on the food) , which may also be pressurised. Typically for less dense food easily able to be lowered in pH terms the immersion in hot water or the heating by steam or hot water is sufficient, but food regarded as more dense or more at risk will be heated at a higher temperature in a retort under pressure. The packaging in the retort may be heated by full immersion in water or steam cooked.
The method of the present invention is directed to decreasing the viability of unwanted microorganisms present on foods, and does not necessarily affect the harmless or useful microorganisms present. Commonly however, the method of the present invention will decrease the viability of all of the microorganisms and may also reduce the activity of any enzymes capable of spoiling food found on foods. Foods usually comprise
numerous types of microorganisms and enzymes, some of which may be detrimental, and some of which are harmless or even useful. For example the cheeses (such as blue vein cheeses), salami and sauerkraut owe their taste and long shelf life to useful, naturally occurring microorganisms and enzymes .
It should be noted that the method of preprocessing food of the present invention is directed to the decrease of viability of detrimental microorganisms, that is, those which adversely affect the health of a consumer or which cause degradation of the foodstuff. This requires only that propagation and growth or the microorganism is inhibited. Optimally the microorganism is rendered more sensitive to being killed during subsequent processing. It is not essential that all the detrimental microorganisms be killed by the process of the present invention. With respect to the detrimental enzymes it is not necessary that the enzymes be destroyed but rather that the enzymes are changed such that they cannot chemically react with or cause detriment to the food.
The types of microorganisms whose viability is intended to be decreased by the method of the present invention include micro-flora and micro-fauna such as bacteria, moulds, fungi, yeast and spores.
Most microorganisms and detrimental enzymes are present at or adjacent the surface or skin of foodstuffs. Accordingly it is often unnecessary for the conditions of the pre-processing method to penetrate into the foodstuff far beyond the surface or skin of the
foodstuff
The types of microorganism present and the degree of detriment caused will vary from foodstuff to foodstuff. Accordingly the method of pre-processing and in particular the environment used with respect to the present invention will vary with the type of food.
The pre-processing takes into account the known growth and survival limits for the microorganisms present on the type of food being processed. The following table (Table 1) lists various species of microorganisms and approximate growth and survival limits where the various other parameters are optimal. For example, the minimum growth temperatures in Table 1 are for growth in optimal, neutral pH, high aw (water activity) microbiological media.
TABLE 1
Source : Campden & Chorleywood Food Research Association; from the Freshline ™ Guide to Modified Atmosphere Packaging, p .26
In yet another embodiment of the invention the pre-processing method may comprise subjecting the foodstuff to an environment comprising a salt solution eg. a spray of a salt solution.
Preferably the pre-processing method of the present invention comprises acidification of the food either by blanching with an acidic solution or mixing an acid into the food.
Typically an acidified blanching solution may be use for fruits, such as apples. Apples have a naturally high acid content and many of the bacteria associated with apples are adapted to tolerate this acid content. However if the level of acid in the environment surrounding the apple is raised during the preprocessing method of the present invention the bacteria die.
Preferably the acid is an organic food acid such as citric acid, tartaric acid, phosphoric acid or gluconic acid and/or its lactones eg. glucono delta lactone .
Typically, the pH of an acidified blanching solution or the pH of the food after mixing with acid is below 4.5, preferably between 4.2 and 4.4.
The method of the present invention for preprocessing food will typically be carried out using a processing apparatus comprising a processing tank into which the food is placed, a reservoir for storage of a
processing liquid which can be added to the tank and optionally a pump for circulating the liquid in the tank, a heater for heating the liquid and detectors/controllers for monitoring and changing physical parameters associated with the environment created in the tank for processing the food. The tank may be able to be pressurised with liquid or gas .
The pre-processing method is not sufficient on its own to provide a shelf-stable product hence further processing is also required. The further processing may comprise any convenient processing for provision of shelf stable foodstuffs, such as sterilization associated with canning or retort technology. A sterilization process may be quite simple but the processing parameters will vary from foodstuff to foodstuff. Where a retort system is being used for sterilization, it is noted that some foodstuffs need full retort processing while other foodstuffs do not require full retort processing. For example, the sterilization process may comprise: i) heating and cooling the pre-stabilized packaged foodstuff in a pressurised retort, ii) heating the packaged pre- stabilised food by an ambient pressure system such as a bath of boiling water, iii) heating via a spiral steam cooker, or iv) heating the foodstuff, putting the foodstuff in sterile packaging and quickly hermetically sealing the packaging as in the canning process.
One of the advantages of the present invention is that the pre-processing may reduce the severity required of the conditions of the main processing. This leads to savings in time and energy expended on the main
processing step, thus contributing to the economy of the process .
It should be noted that the severity of the main processing may be reduced to a level where the main process (or the pre-processing) alone would not provide a shelf stable product, but the combination of the preprocessing method of the present invention plus the main process is sufficient to provide a shelf stable product . In one embodiment the pre-processing method is followed by full retort processing. The food may be subjected to the pre-processing method of the present invention and then the food may be placed in retort quality barrier bags such as those comprising a film of nylon laminated between layers of polypropylene. The bags may then be laid out on trays, allowing for bag expansion during processing. The trays are then placed in a retort and the retort secured. The retort is filled with water to a level near a sensor at the top of the inside of the retort. A vapour space is left for condensation of the heated water. The blowing of steam into the water is then commenced. A circulation pump is started, sucking water from two inlets at the lowest point of the retort and spraying the water back through an opening at the top of th the retort. The recycle time is 5 minutes. The steam blowing is continued until the core of the foodstuff reaches the desired temperature. The hot water is then pumped out and immediately replaced with cold water, reducing the foodstuff temperature to below 55 °C, the temperature at which the cooking process stops .
Typically the apparatus for retort processing
comprises a retort in which the food is placed, hot and cold water reservoirs from which hot and cold water respectively can be pumped into the retort, a boiler for supplying steam to the retort, an air compressor for supplying air to the retort and appropriate sensors and controllers for controlling the supply of water, steam and compressed air to the retort .
In a less rigorous retort processing the packaged food is placed on a conveyor belt which travels slowly through a long (over 8 m) closet. At the end of the conveyor belt the bags drop onto a cooling plate where their temperature is quickly reduced to ambient . In the closet the packaged food may be exposed to heat by spraying hot water or steam such that the internal temperature of the packaging reaches 85°C, and held there for approximately 10 minutes (or more) . Later, as the package travels on the conveyer belt the temperature is reduced to approximately 75°C for a further approximately 10 min, this period depending upon the food being processed.
Typically each processing run using the preprocessing method of the present invention will be used for one particular food or type of food. For example, the pre-processing method may be used to process a batch consisting of a single vegetable such as corn or several different types of vegetables such as corn and peas. The pre-processed vegetables may then be packaged and sent for further processing or they may be mixed with other food such as meat, lentils, cereal, flour, rice, pasta or the like, and the mixture is then packaged and subjected to further processing.
Typically the packaging comprises hermetically sealing the pre-processed food in a polymeric bag or other suitable polymeric container. Other containers suitable for processing and storage of the shelf-stable product will be readily apparent to those skilled in the relevant technology. The container may be evacuated or filled with air or alternatively the air may be replaced by another gas such as nitrogen. The process may be used in a typical canning process such that the canning times and temperatures can be reduced owing to the preprocessing stabilisation stage.
MODES FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION
The invention will now be further described by the following non-limiting Examples:
Example 1
Granny Smith apples (100 kg) were peeled, cored, diced and blemished pieces removed. The pieces of apple were then added to an aqueous solution of citric acid at 70°C for 5 minutes at a pH of between 4.2 and 4.4. The pieces of apple were then removed from the citric acid solution, mixed with some sugar and fed into a packaging machine which loaded portions of diced apple into retort bags which were then hermetically sealed. The bags of diced apple where then placed on a conveyor belt and passed through a sterilization closet. The temperature of the diced apple was raised to 60 °C for 5 minutes before the bags reached the end of the conveyor belt and tumbled off the conveyor belt onto a cooling plate where
the temperature of the diced apples was immediately reduced to room temperature.
Example 2
The process of Example 1 was repeated using fresh Granny Smith apples. Instead of passing the bags of diced apple through a sterilization closet, they were placed in a retort which was filled with hot water for a time sufficient to raise the internal temperature of the bags to 60°C for 5 minutes.
Example 3
The method of the present invention was applied to a food manufactured from a recipe which comprised prime sliced meat, soy sauce, egg, starch, wine, sodium bicarbonate, chilli powder, Chinese pepper, five spice powder, mono-sodium glutamate and sugar. The recipe was prepared by separating the ingredients into dry ingredients (which were already free of microorganisms) and wet ingredients . The wet ingredients were combined and thoroughly mixed and the pH of the mixture measured at 6.7. At this pH most microorganisms will grow prolifically if given sufficient nutrients, moisture, temperature and air.
Stabilization Process
To stabilize the microorganisms, the pH of the wet ingredients was lowered to 4.4 by addition of a food acid. The wet ingredients were then blanched for a short period of time in steam. At this point the proliferation of microorganisms had been halted and a
significant number of microorganisms had been killed.
The wet ingredients were then combined with the dry ingredients before portions of the recipe mixture are added to plastic retort bags which were hermetically sealed.
Sterilisation Process
The plastic retort bags containing the recipe mixture were placed into a retort which was then filled with steam. (It is noted that the same sterilization can be carried out by filling the retort with hot water.) The food was exposed to a temperature of 116°C for 35 to 45 minutes at a pressure of 90 to 95 kPa.
The steam was then pumped out of the retort and the retort bags containing the recipe mixture were left to cool over a 5 minute period in the retort before being removed. The food thus prepared was shelf stable and required no refrigeration. No microorganism growth could be detected and the food maintained most of the organoleptic properties of the freshly cooked ingredients .
The food recipe prepared by the process of the present invention was compared with the results of processing the same food recipe using a process of the prior art. The differences between the process parameters for the two processes are summarized in Table 2 :
TABLE 2
Comparison of the values in Table 2 shows that the current process subjects the food to a lower temperature for a far shorter time compared to the process of the prior art . Accordingly the process of the current invention is not as harsh on the food and is therefore less likely to damage or change the physical or chemical structure of the ingredients . The process of the current invention requires less energy input and is therefore more economical than the process of the prior art.
Example 4
The method of the present invention was applied to a food manufactured from a recipe which comprised prime sliced meat, soy sauce, egg, starch, wine, sodium bicarbonate, chilli powder, Chinese pepper, five spice powder, mono-sodium glutamate and sugar. The recipe was prepared by separating the ingredients into dry ingredients and wet ingredients. The wet ingredients were combined and thoroughly mixed and the pH of the mixture measured at 6.7. At this pH most microorganisms will grow prolifically if given sufficient nutrients, moisture, temperature and air.
Stabilization Process
To stabilize microorganisms, fungi, mould, etc on the food, the wet ingredients were steamed for 2 minutes . Such steaming was sufficient to kill most of the surface organisms mentioned above. At this point the proliferation of microorganisms had been halted and a significant number of microorganisms had been killed.
The pre-processed wet ingredients were then combined with the dry. At this point the pH of the ingredients was lowered by the addition of 1.5% Glucono Delta Lactone diluted in an amount of pure water sufficient to lower the pH of the total ingredients to 4.3. The ingredients were then portioned and placed in retort barrier bags and hermetically sealed.
Sterilisation Process
The plastic retort bags containing the recipe mixture were placed into a retort which was then filled with water. The food was exposed to a temperature of 100°C for 10 minutes then 90°C for 20 min, at ambient pressure.
The steam was then pumped out of the retort and the retort bags containing the recipe mixture were left to cool over a 5 minute period in the retort before being removed. The food thus prepared was shelf stable and required no refrigeration. No microorganism growth could be detected and the food maintained most of the organoleptic properties of the freshly cooked ingredients .
The food recipe prepared by the process of the present invention was compared with the results of processing the same food recipe using a process of the prior art . The differences between the process parameters for the two processes are summarized in Table 3 :
TABLE 3
Example 5
Pieces of filleted fish were blanched in a hot aqueous solution of citric acid at pH 4.3 for 10 minutes. The pieces of blanched fish were then placed in retort bags and the bags hermetically sealed. The sealed bags were placed in a steam retort for 8 minutes at 114°C at a pressure of 81 kPa. The retort was then flushed with cold water, and the temperature in the bags reduced to ambient for 5 minutes. The retort was then refilled with hot steam to raise the internal temperature of the bags to 114°C for 8 minutes. The retort was then drained and the sealed bags were removed.
Example 6
Pre-process/ Stabilisation process
Red kidney beans were soaked in hot water for 1 h then
blanched in boiling water with a solution of 0.5% citric acid for a period of 4 minutes . The beans were removed from the blanching mixture and all liquid allowed to drain off .
Packing
The red kidney beans were then packed in retort quality barrier bags. The package was heat sealed. (In this and subsequent examples, the packaging may be vacuum packed if desired but it is recommended that any vacuum packing should be limited to 30% to minimise damage and to retain a fresh appearance . )
Sterilisation The packages were placed in a retort. The retort was filled with hot water and the temperature was increased to 110°C over 7 minutes. Pressure in the retort was kept at 140 kPa. The beans were kept at 110°C for 30 minutes and then were quickly cooled by removing the hot water and replacing it with cold water.
Example 7
The sweet corn was first de-husked and cleaned
Stabilisation
A blanching solution was prepared containing 1.0% citric acid. The blanching solution was brought to boil and the sweet corn was then blanched for 1 minute at boiling point.
Packaging
The sweet corn was then packed in retort quality barrier
bags (though other appropriate packaging could have been used) . The package was heat sealed.
Sterilisation Because the sweet corn is a dense product requiring a higher degree of heat penetration, the sterilization process was carried out in a retort. The packages were placed in a retort, and the retort was filled with hot water to the stage of the come up time taking 7 minutes to achieve a 115°C water temperature at 140 kPa. The sweet corn was held at 115°C for 30 minutes before being quickly cooled by evacuating the hot water and replacing with chilled water.
Example 8
A chilled Chicken and Curry home replacement meal was purchased from a retailer. The meal was tested for its organoleptic qualities and then for its chemical characteristics. The ingredients were found to have a high pH which hence required adjustment in accordance with the present invention.
Stabilisation A solution of 2% by weight of glucono delta lactone was added to the ingredients sufficient to lower the pH of the ingredients to 4.3, but without substantially altering the basic organoleptic qualities of the meal.
Packaging
The Chicken and Curry meal was then packed in retort quality barrier bags, which were then heat sealed.
Sterilisation
The packaged food was immersed in boiling water (100°C) for 10 minutes and then left to simmer (90°C) for a further 20 minutes . The heated packages were then immediately flushed with chilled water sufficient to cool the contents of the package.
Example 9
Cauliflower was cleaned thoroughly and the florets were separated to sizes suitable for serving.
Stabilisation
A blanching solution was prepared containing 1% citric acid. The blanching solution was brought to boil and the cauliflower blanched for 1 minute. The cauliflower was then immersed in a bath of 1% sodium meta bisulphite at 45°C for 5 minutes.
Packaging
The cauliflower was then packed in retort quality -barrier bags. The package was heat sealed.
Sterilisation The packaged food was immersed in boiling water for 10 minutes and then left to simmer for a further 10 minutes . The heated packaging was then immediately flushed with chilled water sufficient to cool the contents of the package.
Example 10
Ingredients for the manufacture of a hamburger patty were combined, these ingredients including beef combined with egg, flour, garlic, diced onion and spices. The pH of the combined ingredients was determined.
Stabilisation
To the hamburger ingredients a solution of glucono delta lactone was added sufficient to increase the acid level to a pH of 4.3. The hamburger patties were then formed and fried in boiling oil until cooked. The hamburger patties were taken from the fryer and immediately packed.
Packaging The hamburger patties were packed in retort quality barrier bags. The packages were heat sealed.
Sterilisation
The packaged food is immersed in boiling water for 10 minutes and then left to simmer for a further 20 minutes . The heated packaging is then immediately flushed with chilled water sufficient to cool the contents of the package.
At this stage the product is shelf stable
Example 11
Carrot was cleaned and the skin removed. The carrot was then sliced julienne style.
Stabilisation
A blanching solution is prepared containing 1% glucono
delta lactone. The blanching solution was brought to the boil and the julienne carrot blanched for 1 minute at 100°C.
Packaging
The julienne carrots were then packed in retort quality barrier bags. The packages were heat sealed.
Sterilisation The packaged food was immersed in boiling water for 10 minutes and then left to simmer for a further 10 minutes . The heated packaging was then immediately flushed with chilled water sufficient to cool the contents of the package.
While the invention has been explained in relation to its preferred embodiments it is to be understood that various modifications thereof will become apparent to those skilled in the art upon reading the specification. Therefore, it is to be understood that the invention disclosed herein is intended to cover such modifications as fall within the scope of the appended claims.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
The invention is applicable to methods for resisting or preventing the degradation of food, and so is useful in the food preservation art .