KR20120022101A - Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv - Google Patents

Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv Download PDF

Info

Publication number
KR20120022101A
KR20120022101A KR1020100085216A KR20100085216A KR20120022101A KR 20120022101 A KR20120022101 A KR 20120022101A KR 1020100085216 A KR1020100085216 A KR 1020100085216A KR 20100085216 A KR20100085216 A KR 20100085216A KR 20120022101 A KR20120022101 A KR 20120022101A
Authority
KR
South Korea
Prior art keywords
signal
noise
microphone
equation
voice
Prior art date
Application number
KR1020100085216A
Other languages
Korean (ko)
Inventor
조정권
Original Assignee
(주)제이유디지탈
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by (주)제이유디지탈 filed Critical (주)제이유디지탈
Priority to KR1020100085216A priority Critical patent/KR20120022101A/en
Publication of KR20120022101A publication Critical patent/KR20120022101A/en

Links

Images

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G10MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS; ACOUSTICS
    • G10LSPEECH ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES OR SPEECH SYNTHESIS; SPEECH RECOGNITION; SPEECH OR VOICE PROCESSING TECHNIQUES; SPEECH OR AUDIO CODING OR DECODING
    • G10L21/00Speech or voice signal processing techniques to produce another audible or non-audible signal, e.g. visual or tactile, in order to modify its quality or its intelligibility
    • G10L21/02Speech enhancement, e.g. noise reduction or echo cancellation
    • G10L21/0208Noise filtering
    • GPHYSICS
    • G10MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS; ACOUSTICS
    • G10LSPEECH ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES OR SPEECH SYNTHESIS; SPEECH RECOGNITION; SPEECH OR VOICE PROCESSING TECHNIQUES; SPEECH OR AUDIO CODING OR DECODING
    • G10L21/00Speech or voice signal processing techniques to produce another audible or non-audible signal, e.g. visual or tactile, in order to modify its quality or its intelligibility
    • G10L21/02Speech enhancement, e.g. noise reduction or echo cancellation
    • G10L21/0208Noise filtering
    • G10L21/0216Noise filtering characterised by the method used for estimating noise
    • G10L21/0232Processing in the frequency domain
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04RLOUDSPEAKERS, MICROPHONES, GRAMOPHONE PICK-UPS OR LIKE ACOUSTIC ELECTROMECHANICAL TRANSDUCERS; DEAF-AID SETS; PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS
    • H04R1/00Details of transducers, loudspeakers or microphones
    • H04R1/08Mouthpieces; Microphones; Attachments therefor
    • GPHYSICS
    • G10MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS; ACOUSTICS
    • G10LSPEECH ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES OR SPEECH SYNTHESIS; SPEECH RECOGNITION; SPEECH OR VOICE PROCESSING TECHNIQUES; SPEECH OR AUDIO CODING OR DECODING
    • G10L21/00Speech or voice signal processing techniques to produce another audible or non-audible signal, e.g. visual or tactile, in order to modify its quality or its intelligibility
    • G10L21/02Speech enhancement, e.g. noise reduction or echo cancellation
    • G10L21/0208Noise filtering
    • G10L2021/02082Noise filtering the noise being echo, reverberation of the speech
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H03ELECTRONIC CIRCUITRY
    • H03HIMPEDANCE NETWORKS, e.g. RESONANT CIRCUITS; RESONATORS
    • H03H17/00Networks using digital techniques
    • H03H2017/0072Theoretical filter design
    • H03H2017/009Theoretical filter design of IIR filters

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Acoustics & Sound (AREA)
  • Signal Processing (AREA)
  • Computational Linguistics (AREA)
  • Quality & Reliability (AREA)
  • Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Audiology, Speech & Language Pathology (AREA)
  • Human Computer Interaction (AREA)
  • Multimedia (AREA)
  • Circuit For Audible Band Transducer (AREA)
  • Telephone Function (AREA)

Abstract

PURPOSE: A noise reducing device in bidirectional television voice communication and a method thereof are provided to extract a target sound of a user. CONSTITUTION: An FFT(Fast Fourier Transform) module(210) performs conversion from the time domain to the frequency domain. An echo canceller module(220) detects whether it is bidirectional communication. The echo canceller module eliminates an echo. A noise cancelling module(230) presumes a noise interval. The noise cancelling module cancels noise. An IFFT(Inverse FFT) module(240) performs conversion from the frequency domain to the time domain.

Description

Noise reduction method and device in voice communication in two-way television voice communication

According to the present invention, when the microphone (hereinafter referred to as a microphone) is mounted on a two-way television (TV) or a video conferencing system 3 to 5 m away from the user's mouth, the speaker output sound and environmental noise are eliminated, and then only the target sound of the user is transmitted to the other party. The present invention relates to a voice signal processing technology and a related hardware device for enabling smooth two-way voice communication.

The microphone used in the video conferencing system is located within 1 to 2 m from the user's mouth to maintain a high signal-to-noise ratio of the user's target sound and the speaker's output sound from the other party's voice.

According to the prior art, a plurality of microphone modules are arranged and used to prevent the microphone from falling away from the user's mouth. Two-way TV can be used with multiple microphone modules or with a microphone mounted on the remote control, but for the convenience of user management and use, various voice signal processing technologies have been applied so that the microphone module can be attached to the top of the screen. Since the noise and speaker output sound were so large compared to the target sound among the input signals, the signal-to-noise ratio was very bad.

The present invention has been devised to solve the above problems, using a microphone array, a sound collecting housing having a special structure, a powerful echo canceller, and a static noise canceling technology, so that the microphone is 3 to 5 meters away from the mouth. The purpose of the present invention is to develop an effective noise canceling algorithm to enable two-way voice communication, and to provide a method for implementing a hardware system capable of processing the same in real time.

In using the voice signal processing technique according to the present invention for achieving the above object, an echo canceller for reducing the output sound of the speaker input to the microphone and noise by spectral subtraction to effectively remove static noise of the environment By using a canceller, a hardware system for preprocessing of digital signal processing techniques, a microphone array, a collection structure with a special structure, a microphone preamplifier with a low pass filter function, and the analog hardware combined with software By emphasizing only the target sound of the transmission to the other party to facilitate a smooth voice communication.

According to the present invention, since the microphone extracts and transmits only the target sound from a two-way TV, a videoconferencing system, etc., which should be used away from the user's mouth, it is effective for smooth two-way communication in many fields such as communication, education, shopping, and entertainment. Content activation becomes possible.

1 is a diagram illustrating a microphone sound collecting housing.
2 is a diagram illustrating a software flowchart of the invention.
3 is a block diagram of a microphone preamplifier including a summer and a low pass filter.
4 is a diagram illustrating an example of two-way TV voice communication.
5 is a block diagram of the signal flow and system of the echo canceller.
6 is a block diagram of a short channel speech enhancement technique.
7 is a block diagram of a real-time hardware system.

Hereinafter, the theory, configuration and operation of the present invention will be described in detail.

In the flowchart shown in FIG. 2, the signal input from the microphone array includes a target sound, a speaker output sound, and environmental noise, as in the example shown in FIG. 4, and is converted into a frequency domain through a Fourier transform. After detecting, use the line out signal just before the speaker output sound as a reference signal to operate the echo canceller.

Remove the speaker output sound included in the microphone input signal. After estimating the static noise section in the single-channel speech enhancer, we remove the static noise from the environment using a Wiener filter, convert it to a speech signal after outputting it by inverse Fourier transform.

Microphone housing  And Preamp

If the microphone mounted on the top of the TV is 3 to 5m away from the user's mouth, the microphone's sensitivity and amplification rate must be increased to use the user's voice as valid data. The output sound of and the voice signal of the person on the left and right of the TV, not the user in front of the TV, should be suppressed as much as possible to increase the clarity of the target sound of the user. A digital signal processing technique using a microphone array can be used to direct the input signal of the microphone, but the analog-to-digital conversion (ADC) channel is required for the number of microphones, which in turn increases the computational cost of the microprocessor. In order to reduce and preserve original sound, the present invention intends to implement this function as a hardware device. Using the microphone sound collecting housing as shown in Figure 1

In the mid-range sound absorbing unit 110 and the high-sound absorbing unit 120, the attenuation occurs from the left and right instead of the front of the microphone. The amplification gain of about 2 ~ 5dB can be obtained depending on the size of the housing.

The micro-input signal through the microphone collecting housing is added to an adder using an element such as an operational amplifier as shown in FIG. 3 (310). When the signals present in the direction are incident and the signals are summed, attenuation occurs, so that an environmental noise can be suppressed. The signal passing through the summer is amplified to a valid data level in the microphone preamplifier 320 including the low pass filter 330 mainly in the voice signal band, and then passed through the ADC to be converted into a digital signal. When the signal-to-noise ratio of an analog signal before conversion to a digital signal is low, even a high-performance digital signal processing algorithm is difficult to produce a good result, so the sound collecting housing and the analog circuit at the microphone input stage are very important.

Echo canceller

Feedback and howling can be prevented by removing the speaker output sound (echo) of the TV incident to the microphone and then transmitting the signal to the other party. In one example of the bi-directional communication system configured as shown in FIG. 4, if the echo component is not effectively removed, communication is practically impossible due to an echo phenomenon in which a voice is heard by the speaker of the TV used by the user, and a closed loop is formed between the microphone and the speaker. If the loudspeaker volume is formed and the microphone's sensitivity and gain are high, howling occurs, which makes the equipment unusable and can seriously damage the amplifier and the speaker.

As shown in FIG. 5, since the user's voice and the speaker output sound are input to the microphone together, the power of the signal obtained by subtracting the reference signal from the input signal of the microphone by using the line out signal in front of the speaker output sound as a reference signal is obtained. In the frequency domain, a method of updating the coefficient of the adaptive filter to be minimized is used, and a double talk detection is performed through a method of measuring a correlation between a microphone and a reference signal to determine whether a speaker is in the voice (double talk detection). ), The echo is more efficiently removed by adjusting the gain of the output signal.

The other party's signal x (n), the user's speaker output signal y (n), the user's signal s (n), the environmental noise v (n), the error signal e (n), the coefficient

Figure pat00001
Line out signal (relative signal) before speaker output that passed through adaptive filter with
Figure pat00002
Speaking, respectively, are represented by Equations 1 to 3 below.

[Equation 1]

Figure pat00003

[Equation 2]

Figure pat00004

&Quot; (3) "

Figure pat00005

The smoothed power of x (n) in (3)

Figure pat00006
Is expressed as in Equation 4.

&Quot; (4) "

Figure pat00007

The algorithm used for this echo canceller uses a complex least squares average method normalized in the frequency domain.

Voice enhancer

A typical short channel noise cancellation system is performed in the frequency domain and estimates the loudness of speech by determining the attenuation or gain of each frequency component. This is a method to remove the ambient noise by using the characteristic that the noise is less change than the voice in the input signal mixed with voice and noise.

A block diagram of the proposed short channel microphone noise cancellation system is shown in FIG. 6. The short channel microphone sound quality improvement system of FIG. 6 estimates the power spectrum of the noise D (k, l) from the magnitude information of the frequency component Y (k, l) of the input signal y (t) with noise added to the voice, and uses the same. After estimating the gain G (k, l), multiply the input magnitude signal spectrum (noise spectral subtraction) and synthesize the speech using an Inverse Fast Fourier Transform (IFFT).

If the noise section is estimated, the gain controller reduces the magnitude of the input signal. If the gain controller is not used, the residual component after subtracting the frequency component of the noise is output.

As a method of estimating the noise section, the variation of the frequency axis and the time axis among the statistical characteristics of the microphone input signal is calculated, and the threshold is set by experimentally examining the variation of the noise section and the target signal section, and compared with each variation. After that, the noise section and the target signal section are distinguished.

The power of each frequency component in the frequency domain

Figure pat00008
,
Figure pat00009
Average of
Figure pat00010
, The full power of that frame
Figure pat00011
In this case, the normalized change amount in the frequency domain, that is, the frequency flatness, is expressed by Equation 5.

[Equation 5]

Figure pat00012

The power of one frame in the time domain

Figure pat00013
, The average of, the total power of that frame
Figure pat00014
In this case, the normalized change amount in the time domain is expressed by Equation 6.

&Quot; (6) "

Figure pat00015

When the values of Equations 7 and 8 obtained by averaging Infinite Impulse Responses (IIRs) of Equations 5 and 6, respectively, are larger than experimentally obtained thresholds, they may be regarded as target signals.

[Equation 7]

Figure pat00016

[Equation 8]

Figure pat00017

here

Figure pat00018
Is the IIR smoothing coefficient,
Figure pat00019
,
Figure pat00020
Is the experimental threshold.

As another parameter for estimating the desired signal, the IIR average is calculated for the power of the input signal, and the average of the frame power when a certain multiple or more is compared with the current frame power is taken into account. By not doing this, the method of considering the target sound when suddenly a large signal is continuously input is described below.

The IIR average power of the current frame is calculated as in Equation 9.

[Equation 9]

Figure pat00021

here

Figure pat00022
Is the IIR coefficient between 0 and 1,
Figure pat00023
Is the IIR average power of the current frame,
Figure pat00024
Is the power of the previous frame.

Figure pat00025
end
Figure pat00026
When the IIR average is recalculated for power corresponding to a frame less than a certain multiple, it is expressed by Equation 10.

[Equation 10]

Figure pat00027

here

Figure pat00028
Is the IIR smoothing coefficient between 0 and 1,
Figure pat00029
Is the long-term IIR average power up to the current frame,
Figure pat00030
Is the power of the previous frame.

Calculated in Equation 10

Figure pat00031
Does not participate in the average calculation for a rapidly large, i.e., large input signal, and generally represents the frame power level of the noise components.

Therefore, as shown in Equation 11, the power of the current frame of the microphone input signal

Figure pat00032
If it is larger than a certain multiple of, it can be regarded as the purpose signal and protected.

[Equation 11]

Figure pat00033

here

Figure pat00034
Where is the power of the current frame, c is an arbitrary constant obtained experimentally in multiples that can be regarded as the destination signal.

The noise estimator of FIG. 6 uses the spectrum of the noise as a frame determined as the noise section in Equations 7, 8, and 11.

Figure pat00035
In this case, the frame power of the noise section estimated using Equations 9 to 11
Figure pat00036
Frame power of the
Figure pat00037
Calculate the IIR averaged signal to noise ratio with

[Equation 12]

Figure pat00038

here

Figure pat00039
Is the power of the previous frame
Figure pat00040
Is the IIR smoothing coefficient between 0 and 1, abs is the absolute operator.

Using a Wiener filter commonly used among short-channel noise cancellation algorithms and applying Equation 12, the weight multiplied by the frequency component of the input signal is expressed as Equation 13.

[Equation 13]

Figure pat00041

As a variant of the Wiener filter, the gain multiplied by the frequency component of the input signal in FIG. 6 is expressed by Equation 14 below.

[Equation 14]

Figure pat00042

here

Figure pat00043
Is an attenuation level of the noise component, and the larger it reduces the noise component.

To reduce the sudden change in gain, the IIR average of the gain is calculated and multiplied by each frequency component of the microphone input signal as shown in Equation 15.

[Equation 15]

Figure pat00044

here

Figure pat00045
Is a constant between 0 and 1 that is determined experimentally.

Hardware system for real time processing

FIG. 7 is a block diagram of an independent hardware system for operating a program implementing the software flowchart shown in FIG. 2 in real time.

A real-time processing board based on an Arm 920T processor or a general purpose processor and a Philips CODEC UDA1341TS or AD (analog-to-digital) converter was developed based on the block diagram shown in FIG.

The input signals from the four microphones are summed into one channel by an adder 700 composed of op-amps, amplified by a preamplifier 710 with a first-order lowpass circuit with a cutoff frequency of 17KHz, and a UDA1341TS stereo codec. At 720 it is converted to a digital value. After the program implemented in the assembly language of the C and the Arm 920T is optimized, the algorithm shown in the flowchart of FIG. 2 is optimized and operated in the Arm 920T 740 to remove the static components of the input signal and the static noise of the environment in real time. The user-oriented hardware is designed to automatically store the parameter values used in the EEPROM 790 to maintain the optimal state adapted to the user environment. In order to change the function in detail according to the user's environment, a button 730 and a connection device 750 can be connected to a PC or other device to exchange data. 760). Equipped with a copy protection security chip 770 for copyright protection of the software, LED is displayed on the front panel 780 to indicate the operation status of the program and whether to use the button to facilitate the user's use and control of the equipment. It was.

The above description of a speaker output sound or a structure or hardware system designed to remove environmental noise included in a microphone input signal and a signal processing algorithm in an apparatus such as a two-way TV with a distance between a microphone and a user is illustrated and described. Presented for. It is not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to the precise form of equations or drawings. Many modifications and variations are possible in light of the above teachings, and some combinations of the mathematical formulas and embodiments may be used. It is intended that the scope of the invention be limited not by this detailed description or figures, or by equations, but by the claims appended hereto.

200: signal input module of the microphone array
210: Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) module for transforming from the time domain to the frequency domain
220: echo canceller module for detecting whether bidirectional communication and removing the echo component
230: Module for estimating noise section and removing noise by subtracting spectrum by Wiener filter
240: IFFT (Inverse FFT) module converts from the frequency domain to the time domain

Claims (6)

In a two-way TV or videoconferencing system where the distance between the microphone and the user's mouth is 3 to 5 meters, the other party's voice is output to the speaker to remove the other party's voice from the microphone input signal along with the user's voice, and to suppress environmental noise in the surroundings. By the microphone housing having a structure devised in the present invention to enable a smooth two-way voice communication; A preamplifier section having a summer and a low pass filter function; A microprocessor and main memory unit for executing echo cancellation and speech enhancement programs; A data storage unit for storing a driving driver of a program and hardware equipment; A flash memory unit incorporating a firmware program for driving electronic components and equipment when the power is turned on; A security chip for copy protection of the program; And a signal processing algorithm and hardware for extracting and reinforcing a target sound of a user and transmitting the same to a counterpart in a hardware system including a codec for converting an analog signal into a digital signal. A noise estimation method for removing static noise in the surrounding environment,
Equation 7 after converting the microphone input signal into the frequency domain
Figure pat00046

By the amount of change in the frequency component,
Figure pat00047

By the amount of change in the time domain,
Figure pat00048

By the IIR average power of the current frame,
Figure pat00049

By the long term IIR average power of the current frame,
Figure pat00050

And estimating whether the signal of the current frame is a noise or a target signal by comparing the power of the current frame with an experimentally obtained threshold, and a bidirectional communication method and system characterized by the same.
To subtract the noise component estimated in claim 2 from the target signal, Equation 12
Figure pat00051

Compute the IIR average for the ratio of the input signal to the estimated noise signal, such as
Figure pat00052
Based on the Wiener filter of Equation 14
Figure pat00053

As the IIR mean for the gain of
Figure pat00054
And a noise canceling method for minimizing a noise component in a target signal section by multiplying each frequency component of a microphone input signal by the signal.
The method according to claim 1, wherein the line out signal before the speaker output is used as a reference signal, and Equation 3 is used to remove the reference signal from the microphone input signal.
Figure pat00055
An echo canceller based on an adaptive filter in a transform domain using coefficients such as and a two-way speech communication method using a static noise canceling technique by the spectral subtraction method as described in claim 3 with respect to an output sound of an echo canceller.
Method of suppressing environmental noise and giving the maximum gain in the direction to the target sound using the microphone housing having the structure as shown in FIG. 1 and the summer 310 of FIG. 3 and a two-way voice communication system using the same. 1. A voice communication method and system incorporating a microphone housing such as FIG. 1, a preamplifier comprising the summer and low pass filter of FIG. 3, and an echo canceller of claim 4 and a short channel noise canceller of claim 3.
KR1020100085216A 2010-09-01 2010-09-01 Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv KR20120022101A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
KR1020100085216A KR20120022101A (en) 2010-09-01 2010-09-01 Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
KR1020100085216A KR20120022101A (en) 2010-09-01 2010-09-01 Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv

Related Child Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
KR1020120120763A Division KR101402287B1 (en) 2012-10-29 2012-10-29 Apparatus for eliminating noise

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
KR20120022101A true KR20120022101A (en) 2012-03-12

Family

ID=46130279

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
KR1020100085216A KR20120022101A (en) 2010-09-01 2010-09-01 Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv

Country Status (1)

Country Link
KR (1) KR20120022101A (en)

Cited By (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US10313789B2 (en) 2016-06-16 2019-06-04 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Electronic device, echo signal cancelling method thereof and non-transitory computer readable recording medium
CN114242106A (en) * 2020-09-09 2022-03-25 中车株洲电力机车研究所有限公司 Voice processing method and device
CN114242096A (en) * 2021-08-20 2022-03-25 北京士昌鼎科技有限公司 Noise reduction system based on time-frequency domain
WO2022139899A1 (en) * 2020-12-23 2022-06-30 Intel Corporation Acoustic signal processing adaptive to user-to-microphone distances

Cited By (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US10313789B2 (en) 2016-06-16 2019-06-04 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Electronic device, echo signal cancelling method thereof and non-transitory computer readable recording medium
CN114242106A (en) * 2020-09-09 2022-03-25 中车株洲电力机车研究所有限公司 Voice processing method and device
WO2022139899A1 (en) * 2020-12-23 2022-06-30 Intel Corporation Acoustic signal processing adaptive to user-to-microphone distances
CN114242096A (en) * 2021-08-20 2022-03-25 北京士昌鼎科技有限公司 Noise reduction system based on time-frequency domain

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN110169041B (en) Method and system for eliminating acoustic echo
EP2749016B1 (en) Processing audio signals
CN104158990B (en) Method and audio receiving circuit for processing audio signal
US8842851B2 (en) Audio source localization system and method
US8396234B2 (en) Method for reducing noise in an input signal of a hearing device as well as a hearing device
US20190273988A1 (en) Beamsteering
WO2011129725A1 (en) Method and arrangement for noise cancellation in a speech encoder
CN106713570B (en) Echo cancellation method and device
US9106196B2 (en) Sound field spatial stabilizer with echo spectral coherence compensation
EP2700161B1 (en) Processing audio signals
US20100184488A1 (en) Sound signal adjuster adjusting the sound volume of a distal end voice signal responsively to proximal background noise
EP2741481B1 (en) Subband domain echo masking for improved duplexity of spectral domain echo suppressors
KR20100003530A (en) Apparatus and mehtod for noise cancelling of audio signal in electronic device
KR20120022101A (en) Noise reduction method and device in voice communication of iptv
US9099973B2 (en) Sound field spatial stabilizer with structured noise compensation
US9743179B2 (en) Sound field spatial stabilizer with structured noise compensation
KR102517939B1 (en) Capturing far-field sound
CN111970610B (en) Echo path detection method, audio signal processing method and system, storage medium, and terminal
US9729967B2 (en) Feedback canceling system and method
CA2840730C (en) Maintaining spatial stability utilizing common gain coefficient
US10692514B2 (en) Single channel noise reduction
KR101306868B1 (en) Un-identified system modeling method and audio system for howling cancelation using it
KR101402287B1 (en) Apparatus for eliminating noise
KR20150045203A (en) Apparatus for eliminating noise
Favrot et al. Adaptive equalizer for acoustic feedback control

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
A201 Request for examination
E902 Notification of reason for refusal
A107 Divisional application of patent
E902 Notification of reason for refusal
E601 Decision to refuse application