EP0204650B1

EP0204650B1 - Valve assembly for securing a cover to a valve body with fasteners which are free of tensile stress

Info

Publication number: EP0204650B1
Application number: EP86630097A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Michael John Sandling
Original assignee: Xomox Corp
Current assignee: Xomox Corp
Priority date: 1985-06-07
Filing date: 1986-05-28
Publication date: 1990-10-10
Anticipated expiration: 2006-05-28
Also published as: JPH0633829B2; CA1222994A; JPS61286683A; US4610266A; EP0204650A2; EP0204650A3; DE3674837D1

Description

The invention relates generally to valves and more particularly to an assembly for securing a removable valve cover to a valve body with fasteners which do not experience tensile stress in order to substantially reduce the possibility that the fasteners will fail under the influence of high process media pressure. The invention will be specifically disclosed in connection with a valve assembly having a valve cover removably secured to an access opening in a valve body by threaded fasteners held in compression to sealingly close the opening.
A typical valve of the type according to the precharacterizing portion of independent claim 1 is disclosed in US-A--4 333 632. The known valve includes a valve body having a movable valve member internally disposed therein. The movable valve member is positioned in a fluid flow passage extending between an inlet and an outlet of the body for selectively controlling fluid flow through the flow passage. Movement of the internally disposed valve member is usually effectuated by an actuating shaft interconnecting the valve member with an actuating mechanism, either manual or automatic, positioned externally of the housing. The actuating shaft is generally rigidly affixed to the valve member for common movement therewith.
In orderto permit both assembly of the movable valve member within the body and subsequent maintenance, the valve body generally has an access opening which is closable by a removable valve cover. The actuating shaft may, as is the usual case, extend through an aperture in this cover. Fastening elements, most generally threaded members such as bolts or screws, may be used to removably secure the cover to the valve body. Screws, for example, are commonly used in an arrangement in which they extend through the cover and are received by threaded openings in the valve body to releasably join the cover to the valve body. Alternatively, bolts extending through aligned apertures in the valve cover and flanges on the valve body are used in another common arrangement for securing valve covers to valve bodies. The bolts may be removably held by nuts on the opposite flange side.
When used in a pressurized system, a valve is internally subjected to the pressure of the fluid process media flowing through the valve. This process media pressure tends to separate the valve cover from the valve body and imparts a tensile stress on the fastening elements connecting these two elements. In high pressure applications, the process media pressure, and the resulting tensile stress on the fasteners, may be quite substantial. Under standard engineering practices, fasteners of sufficient size and strength are selected to withstand tensile stresses well in excess of those to which the fasteners are expected to be subjected in operation.
Unfortunately, fasteners occassionally have material faults which escape detection, even when high quality inspection standards are employed. Such faults may, for example, take the form of a microscopic cracks in the material, and will substantially reduce the strength of the fastener material. Since tensile stresses tend to pull the material apart and accentuate microscopic cracks, such faults make fasteners under tensile stress especially prone to failure.
In addition to the problems of improper design and inadequate quality standards, many materials, including metals commonly used for bolts, -screws and other similar fasteners, are subject to a phenomenon known as stress corrosion cracking. Although the mechanics of this phenomenon are not fully understood, stress corrosion cracking appears to result from exposure of the materials to particular elements. Chlorine and chlorine compounds, for example, attack certain stainless steel materials and cause the materials to fail under stress conditions. Other elements, such as sulfides, attack other metals and result in stress corrosion cracking. Even trace amounts of the attacking elements can cause the stress corrosion cracking phenomenon.
High performance materials, such as bolts or screws under high tensile stress, are particulary susceptible to stress corrosion cracking. The problem is particularly pronounced in high pressure valves located in chemical processing plants where many of the attacking elements, airborne or otherwise, come into contact with the cover fasteners and where the high pressure of process fluids commonly impart substantial tensile stress to bolts, screws or other types of fasteners securing a cover to a valve body. If the pressure of the process media exceeds the tensile strength of the fastener material, the fasteners will fail. Injury or death to persons working in proximity to the failed valve may result. To make the problem worse, stress corrosion cracking is not detectable from visual inspection and a fastener suffering from stress corrosion cracking may appear completely normal immediately prior to failure.
Reference is also made to the US-A-4 272 057 which discloses a flexible wire for retaining a cover member in a retaining skirt of the valve assembly body. The valve assembly of US-A-4 272 057 is not of the type having seal means requiring compression axially of the actuating shaft of the valve to seal the access opening.
The object of the invention is to provide a valve assembly of the type referred to which substantially reduces the susceptibility to failure which results from stress corrosion cracking and accordingly reduces the risk that a valve cover will be blown off by the pressure of a process media being controlled by a valve.
This is achieved in accordance with the invention by the features recited in the characterizing portion of independent claim 1.
The fasteners for applying sealing force to the seal means and the retaining element are free of tensile stress and accordingly substantially less susceptible to operational failure.
Advantageous features of the valve assembly are recited in the dependent claims 2 through 4.
The accompanying drawings incorporated in and forming a part of the specification illustrate several aspects of the valve assembly, and together with the description serve to expain the principles of the invention. In the drawings:

Fig. 1 is a three quarter sectional view of a prior art valve illustrating a conventional method of interconnecting a valve body and a valve cover;
Fig. 2 is a three quarter sectional view of a valve similar to the valve of Fig. 1, but employing the principles of the present invention wherein the fasteners are free of tensile stress;
Fig. 3 is a fragmentary cross-sectional view of the valve of Fig. 2 depicting the valve cover and seal assembly; and
Fig. 4 is a sectional view, taken along line 4-4 in Fig. 3, showing the valve cover and mounting assembly for securing the valve cover against movement along the axial direction of the actuating shaft.

Reference will now be made in detail to the present preferred embodiment of the invention, an example of which is illustrated in the accompanying drawings.
Referrring initially to the prior art valve depicted in Fig. 1, a tapered sleeve plug valve generally identified by the numeral 10 is shown. The valve 10 includes a valve body 12 having an internal fluid flow passage 14 extending therethrough. The flow passage 14 provides fluid communication between an inlet 16 and an outlet 18 (partially obscured in Fig. 1, but identified by an arrow). The valve body 12 has an access opening 20 intermediate the inlet 16 and outlet 18. This access opening 20 provides access to a movable valve member 22, specifically illustrated as a tapered plug in the illustration, which is moved within the valve body 12 to selectively control the flow of fluid through the flow passage 14. The plug 22 has a through passageway 24 which is selectively brought into and out of registry with the flow passage 14 in accordance with the rotation of the plug 22. A sleeve 28 formed of a plastic such as fluorinated hydrocarbon or other material inert to process media flowing through flow passage 14, is shown interposed between plug 22 and the valve body 12. The illustrated sleeve 28 is apertured in correspondency with the plug 22 so as to permit fluid flow through the plug passageway 24 whenever the plug passageway 24 is brought into registry with the flow passage 14 extending through the valve body.
Rotational movement of the plug 22 is effectuated by an actuating shaft 30 rigidly affixed to the plug 22. The actuating shaft 30 extends through an aperture 32 in a valve cover 38 for interconnection with an actuating mechanism (not shown) disposed external to the valve housing 12. The outboard end of the illustrated shaft 30 has a flat 36 designed to facilitate such an interconnection.
The access opening 20 of the prior art valve 10 is closed by a removable cover 38, which cover 38 is removably secured to the valve body 12 through the agency of a plurality of bolts 40. The bolts 40 extend through aligned apertures (not shown) in correspondingly angularly spaced flanges 42, 44 which extend radially outwardly from valve cover 38 and valve body 12, respectively. Nuts (not shown) may be used to secure the bolts 40 to the underside of the flanges 44. Alternatively, the aperature in flange 44 may be closed ended and threaded for threadably receiving the bolts 40.
As will be apparent to those skilled in the art, fluid pressure of a process media flowing through the flow passage 14 tends to separate the cover 38 from the valve body 12. This separating force places a tensile stress on the bolts 40 and such bolts 40 are therefore particularly prone to failure. Moreover, as previously noted, high tensile stress makes such bolts particularly susceptible to stress corrosion cracking.
The aforementioned problems of the prior art are avoided by the valve 100 depicted in Fig. 2. The valve construction of Fig. 2 incorporates the principles of applicant's invention and eliminates tensile stress in the valve cover fasteners. As illustrated, the valve 100 is similar to the prior art valve 10 in Fig. 1 and, accordingly, components of the valve 100 will be identified by numbers which exceed by one hundred the identifying numbers used in describing corresponding components of Fig. 1.
The illustrated valve 100, like the valve 10, includes a movable valve member in the form of a tapered plug 122 disposed within an internal flow passage 114 for controlling fluid flow through the passage 114. Such fluid flow control is achieved by selectively bringing a through passageway 124 in the plug 122 into and out of registry with the flow passage 114 by rotating the plug 122 about the axis of an actuating shaft 130. This top portion of the plug 122 includes a shoulder 150 to which the activating shaft 130 is rigidly affixed. The activating shaft 130 extends out of the valve body 112 through the access opening 120.
Unlike the valve of Fig. 1, the preferred and illustrated embodiment of applicant's invention depicted in Fig. 2 includes a retaining skirt 152, preferably of cylindrical configuration, extending outwardly from the periphery of the access opening 120. As illustrated, the retaining skirt 152 is concentrically disposed about the actuating shaft 130.
A valve cover 154 is fitted and secured within retaining skirt 152 to close the access opening 120. Preferably, the valve cover 154 is removably secured within retaining skirt so as to permit removal of the removable valve member 122 and of the associated sealing components. In the present preferred form of the invention, the cover 154 is secured to the interior cylindrical surface of the retaining skirt 152 by a keying arrangement described hereinafter. Whatever means are used for securing the valve cover 154 within the retaining skirt 152, it is important that the valve cover 154 is retained against axial movement out of the retaining skirt 152.
In the illustrated form of the invention, a V-shaped sealing wedge ring 156 (best seen in Fig. 3) is supported on the plug shoulder 150 and received within a correspondingly inverted V-shaped groove formed in a diaphragm seal 158. in the preferred form, the ring 156 and the diaphragm 158 are formed of a semiflexible plastic such as fluorinated hydrocarbon or other material inert to a wide range of process media. The plastic diaphragm 158 has a centrally disposed aperature defined by the inner surface 160 of the V-shaped wedge receiving groove. This inner groove surface 160 compressingly engages the actuating shaft 130 adjacent the plug shoulder 150.
A metal diaphragm 162 is placed over the plastic diaphragm 158. The diaphragm 162 is of larger diameter than the diaphragm 158 and is received in a separate counterbore of the valve body 112 so as to protect the plastic diaphragm 158 from damage when the sealing arrangement for the access opening 120 is tightened, which tightening will be further described below. The metal diaphragm 162 has a central aperture which is larger than that of plastic diaphragm 158 and which receives both the actuating shaft 130 and the inverted V-shaped groove-forming protruber- ance of plastic diaphragm 158.
A thrust collar 164 having an obliquely oriented interior underside surface is on the metal diaphragm 162 with the obliquely oriented surface in engagement with the outside surface of the V-shaped groove. The thrust collar 164 acts to ensure a uniform sealing pressure against the outside of the V-shaped groove, and this sealing pressure is transmitted through the wedge ring 156 to provide a sealing pressure between the inside surface of the V-shaped groove and the actuating shaft 134. Thrust is adjustably applied to the thrust collar 164 for varying the sealing pressure about the actuating shaft 130 by a series of adjusting bolts 166.
As indicated above, conventional arrangements for securing a valve cover to a valve body and sealing about the periphery of the access opening places tensile stress on the fastener elements. In contrast, the present invention accomplishes these objections by securing the valve cover with fasteners which are placed in compression, and are free of tensile stress. As most clearly seen in Fig. 3, the valve cover 154 is secured within retaining skirt 152 by a retaining wire 170 inserted in a retaining groove formed by opposing slots of generally semi-circular configuration in the outer cylindrical surface of the cover 154 and inner cylindrical surface of the retaining skirt, respectively. The retaining wire 170, which acts as a key member, prevents axial movement of the valve cover 154.
A diaphragm collar 172 is concentrically disposed about the thrust collar 164 for applying sealing pressure between the metal diaphragm 162 and the periphery of the access opening 120. Sealing pressure is applied to the diaphragm collar 172 by a plurality of threaded fastening elements 176 extending through the valve cover in angularly spaced parallel relationship to each other. When advanced toward the diaphragm collar 172 beyond initial contact, the fastening elements 176 cooperate with the retaining ring 170 to secure the valve cover 154 within the retaining skirt 152 and to apply an adjustable sealing force against the valve body.
Significantly, in accordance with the broad aspects of the invention, the fastening members 176, as well as the retaining wire 170 are placed in compression, and are free of tensile stress. As suggested above, placing these fastening elements in compression and eliminating tensile stress reduces the risk that the fasteners will fail during operation and reduces the susceptibility of the fasteners to stress corrosion cracking.
The valve cover 154 is preferably removable to permit servicing and repair to valve 100. With reference to Fig. 4, one manner of inserting the retaining wire 170 into the groove between the valve cover 154 and retaining skirt 152 is illustrated. An opening 180 is provided through the retaining skirt 152 and the retaining wire is longitudinally advanced through this opening 180. As the retaining wire 170 is so advanced, it follows the circumferential path formed by the retaining groove. This advancement is limited by a stop pin 182 fixed into the outer periphery of the valve cover and extending into the groove. Once the retaining wire is inserted, the opening 180 is closed by a plug 184. Preferably, the opening 180 and plug 184 are matchingly threaded and the plug 184 may be readily inserted and removed. It should be apparent from the above, the plug 184 is removed and the retaining wire 170 withdrawn to remove the valve cover 154 from the body 112.
In summary, numerous benefits have been described which result from employing the concepts of the invention. The assembly removably secures a valve cover to a valve body with fasteners which are free of tensile stress. Eliminating the application of tensile stress to the fasteners renders the valve less susceptible to operational failure. Eliminating the application of tensile stresses in the fasteners reduces failures from improper design and material faults. Moreover, the elimination of tensile stress in the fasteners significantly reduces the chances of failure due to stress corrosion cracking. Securing a valve cover with fasteners which are free of tensile stress eliminates the concern of many design engineers who have in the past been relegated to selecting a material for valve fasteners which was not susceptible to stress corrosion cracking from the elements exposed to the fasteners.
The principles of the invention are not limited to plug valves. Also, other types of fasteners and methods of securing the valve cover to the valve body may be used.

Claims

1. A valve assembly for securing a valve cover to a valve body comprising:

a valve body (112), said valve body (112) having an inlet (116) and an outlet (118) and a fluid flow passage (114) extending therebetween;

a valve member (122) movably disposed within the flow passage (114) of said valve body (112), said valve member (122) being operative to control fluid flow through said flow passage (114) in accordance with the position of said valve member (122) relative to said valve body (112), said valve body (112) having an access opening (120) for assembling and accessing said valve member (122);

an actuating shaft (130) affixed to said valve member (122), said acuating shaft (130) being adapted to mechanically interface with an actuating element positioned external to said valve body (112) for effectuating movement of said valve member (122) within said valve body (112);

a cover member (154) for said access opening (120), said cover member (154) being secured to said valve body (112) against axial movement along said actuating shaft (130) and including an opening for said actuating shaft (130);

seal means (158, 162) for sealing said access opening (120) of the valve body (112), with said seal means (158, 162) being pressed against said valve body (112) axially of said actuating shaft (130); and

retaining means for securing said cover member (154) with respect to said valve body (112);
characterized in that said retaining means comprises a retaining skirt (152) extending outwardly from the periphery of the access opening (120), at least one retaining element (170) partly surrounding the cover member (154) and received in a retaining groove formed in the outer circumferential surface of the cover member (154) and the inner circumferential surface of the retaining skirt (152), that a collar (172) is disposed between said cover member (154) and said seal means (158, 162), and at least one threaded fastener element (176) threadably received in said cover member (154) through which it extends and adjustable therein to be tightened axially of said actuating shaft (130) against said collar (172) thereby applying a sealing pressure to said seal means (158, 162) and said valve body (112) while loading said fastener element (176) and said retaining element (170) in compression.

2. Valve assembly according to claim 1, characterized in that said seal means (158, 162) includes a diaphragm seal (158, 162) withs the outer circumferential portion thereof being pressed by said threaded fastener element (176) and said collar (172) against said valve body (112), said diaphragm seal (158, 162) having a centrally disposed aperture through which said actuating shaft (130) extends, that a further collar (164) is concentrically arranged to said first mentioned collar (172) between said cover member (154) and said diaphragm seal (158, 162) and that at least one further threaded fastener element (166) is threadably received in said cover member (154) through which it extends and adjustable therein against the further collar (164) to apply a compressive sealing force between the diaphragm seal (158, 162) and the actuating shaft (130).

3. Valve assembly according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that said at least one retaining element (170) is a key member extending between the cover member (154) and the retaining skirt (152).

4. Valve assembly according to claim 3, characterized in that said key member includes a flexible retaining wire (170).