CN113046892A - Novel three-proofing fabric - Google Patents

Novel three-proofing fabric Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN113046892A
CN113046892A CN201911377209.9A CN201911377209A CN113046892A CN 113046892 A CN113046892 A CN 113046892A CN 201911377209 A CN201911377209 A CN 201911377209A CN 113046892 A CN113046892 A CN 113046892A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
fiber
flame
fabric
retardant
sol
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
CN201911377209.9A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
冉国庆
胡金龙
王宝剑
王颖
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Sol Flame Retardant Fiber Ltd
Original Assignee
Sol Flame Retardant Fiber Ltd
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Sol Flame Retardant Fiber Ltd filed Critical Sol Flame Retardant Fiber Ltd
Priority to CN201911377209.9A priority Critical patent/CN113046892A/en
Publication of CN113046892A publication Critical patent/CN113046892A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D02YARNS; MECHANICAL FINISHING OF YARNS OR ROPES; WARPING OR BEAMING
    • D02GCRIMPING OR CURLING FIBRES, FILAMENTS, THREADS, OR YARNS; YARNS OR THREADS
    • D02G3/00Yarns or threads, e.g. fancy yarns; Processes or apparatus for the production thereof, not otherwise provided for
    • D02G3/02Yarns or threads characterised by the material or by the materials from which they are made
    • D02G3/04Blended or other yarns or threads containing components made from different materials
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D02YARNS; MECHANICAL FINISHING OF YARNS OR ROPES; WARPING OR BEAMING
    • D02GCRIMPING OR CURLING FIBRES, FILAMENTS, THREADS, OR YARNS; YARNS OR THREADS
    • D02G3/00Yarns or threads, e.g. fancy yarns; Processes or apparatus for the production thereof, not otherwise provided for
    • D02G3/44Yarns or threads characterised by the purpose for which they are designed
    • D02G3/443Heat-resistant, fireproof or flame-retardant yarns or threads
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D02YARNS; MECHANICAL FINISHING OF YARNS OR ROPES; WARPING OR BEAMING
    • D02GCRIMPING OR CURLING FIBRES, FILAMENTS, THREADS, OR YARNS; YARNS OR THREADS
    • D02G3/00Yarns or threads, e.g. fancy yarns; Processes or apparatus for the production thereof, not otherwise provided for
    • D02G3/44Yarns or threads characterised by the purpose for which they are designed
    • D02G3/449Yarns or threads with antibacterial properties
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D10INDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10BINDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10B2201/00Cellulose-based fibres, e.g. vegetable fibres
    • D10B2201/20Cellulose-derived artificial fibres
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D10INDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10BINDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10B2321/00Fibres made from polymers obtained by reactions only involving carbon-to-carbon unsaturated bonds
    • D10B2321/10Fibres made from polymers obtained by reactions only involving carbon-to-carbon unsaturated bonds polymers of unsaturated nitriles, e.g. polyacrylonitrile, polyvinylidene cyanide
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D10INDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10BINDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10B2331/00Fibres made from polymers obtained otherwise than by reactions only involving carbon-to-carbon unsaturated bonds, e.g. polycondensation products
    • D10B2331/14Fibres made from polymers obtained otherwise than by reactions only involving carbon-to-carbon unsaturated bonds, e.g. polycondensation products polycondensates of cyclic compounds, e.g. polyimides, polybenzimidazoles
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D10INDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10BINDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10B2401/00Physical properties
    • D10B2401/13Physical properties anti-allergenic or anti-bacterial
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D10INDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10BINDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10B2401/00Physical properties
    • D10B2401/16Physical properties antistatic; conductive
    • DTEXTILES; PAPER
    • D10INDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10BINDEXING SCHEME ASSOCIATED WITH SUBLASSES OF SECTION D, RELATING TO TEXTILES
    • D10B2501/00Wearing apparel
    • D10B2501/04Outerwear; Protective garments

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Mechanical Engineering (AREA)
  • Textile Engineering (AREA)
  • Woven Fabrics (AREA)

Abstract

The invention discloses a novel three-proofing fabric which is formed by blending the following components in percentage by mass: 20 to 60 percent of SOL FR, 10 to 40 percent of polyimide fiber, 20 to 50 percent of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 1 to 5 percent of conductive fiber; or is formed by blending the following components in percentage by mass: 20-60% of SOL FR, 10-40% of polyimide fiber, 20-50% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 10-30% of pre-oxidized silk. The novel three-proofing fabric is a high-performance fabric with the functions of preventing heat radiation, splashing and electric arc. The fabric has the characteristics of good comfort, good flame retardant property, high thermal protection property, good bacteriostasis, deodorization and the like.

Description

Novel three-proofing fabric
Technical Field
The invention belongs to the technical field of textile disciplines, and relates to a novel three-proofing fabric.
Background
Welding is an important processing procedure in the industries of vehicles, shipbuilding, containers and the like, and a welder needs to wear a splash-proof protective garment in operation in order to avoid the injury to human bodies caused by the splashing of electric welding slag and metal molten drops on the garment.
The market of the welding protective clothing mainly uses pure cotton after finishing or flame-retardant protective clothing (such as CN107604656) which is subjected to surface soaking treatment after the cellulose fiber and the synthetic fiber are blended, and uses pure flame-retardant polyester and aramid fiber flame-retardant protective clothing as auxiliary materials. The flame-retardant protective clothing soaked by the flame retardant has the defects of poor comfort, reduced flame retardance after washing and the like. The pure flame-retardant polyester welding protective clothing is easy to burn due to the fact that splashed electric welding slag or molten metal objects are molten, and the flame-retardant polyester fabric is easy to generate static electricity and poor in comfort; the aramid fiber flame-retardant protective clothing has poor moisture absorption and air permeability and poor thermal stability.
The protective clothing of the stokehole worker in the metallurgical industry needs to prevent splashing and heat radiation, and at present, thick after-finishing flame-retardant protective clothing or composite aluminum film protective clothing is mostly adopted, so that the comfort is poor.
The invention relates to a novel three-proofing fabric which is a high-performance fabric with the functions of preventing heat radiation, splashing and electric arc. The fabric has the characteristics of good comfort, good flame retardant property, high thermal protection property, good bacteriostasis, deodorization and the like.
Disclosure of Invention
The technical problems solved by the invention are as follows: in order to overcome the defects of poor comfort of the welding protective clothing and melt dripping of the pure polyester protective clothing on the market at present, the novel three-proofing fabric which is good in comfort, free of melt dripping, high in flame retardance and permanently flame-retardant is obtained.
The invention relates to a novel three-proofing fabric which is realized by the following two technical schemes and is formed by blending the following components in percentage by mass:
1. 20-60% of SOL FR, 10-40% of polyimide fiber, 20-50% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 1-5% of conductive fiber. More preferred compositions are: 30-50% of SOL FR, 20-40% of polyimide fiber, 25-40% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 1-5% of conductive fiber.
2. 20-60% of SOL FR, 10-40% of polyimide fiber, 20-50% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 10-30% of pre-oxidized silk. More preferred compositions are: SOL FR 30-50%, polyimide fiber 15-30%, flame-retardant acrylic fiber 20-40%, and pre-oxidized silk 15-25%.
The novel three-proofing fabric adopts a short-process spinning process, and the process flow is as follows: automatic cotton feeding → cotton carding → one drawing → two drawing → three drawing → four drawing → roving → spun yarn → automatic bobbin winding.
Wherein, SOL FR refers to the flame-retardant regenerated cellulose fiber produced by Beijing Sailolan flame-retardant fiber Co., Ltd, and other fibers adopt the varieties widely sold in the market. The SOL FR is specifically named as multi-element synergistic flame-retardant regenerated cellulose fiber, and the fiber is formed by forming a silk fiber structure by a cross-linked network of cellulose, multi-element synergistic flame retardant and cationic cross-linking agent. The manufacturing process of the fiber comprises the following steps: the method takes alpha-cellulose, multi-element synergistic flame retardant and cationic cross-linking agent as raw materials and comprises the steps of dipping, squeezing, crushing, ageing, yellowing, filtering, glue mixing, balancing, spinning, drafting, cross-linking, refining and drying. See application No.: 201810777003.4.
The SOFFR fiber belongs to an organic silicon nitrogen series flame-retardant regenerated cellulose fiber, has good moisture absorption and air permeability, high flame retardance, a limit oxygen index of more than 35 percent, a fiber framework still maintained after being burnt at a high temperature of 1100 ℃, and high thermal protection performance.
The polyimide fiber has high temperature resistance and high flame retardant performance, the initial thermal decomposition temperature is higher than 500 ℃, and the limiting oxygen index is higher than 36%.
The pre-oxidized fiber has high flame retardance, the limiting oxygen index is more than 40%, the pre-oxidized fiber has excellent thermal stability, the fiber is not melted, softened and contracted in combustion, no molten drop exists, and the heat insulation effect is good.
The flame-retardant acrylic fibers have soft and plump handfeel and good heat resistance, and the limited oxygen index is more than 32 percent.
The fabric blended by the fibers not only keeps the comfort of the regenerated cellulose fiber fabric, but also has high flame retardant property, good thermal stability and good thermal protection property, and is suitable for being used as the fabric of protective clothing in the industries of metallurgy, coal, chemical industry, shipbuilding and the like.
The invention provides a novel three-proofing fabric, which is subjected to vertical combustion detection by an authoritative detection mechanism according to GB/T5455, and meets the standard A-level requirement of flame-retardant protective clothing; antibacterial detection is carried out according to GB/T20944.3, and the antibacterial function is realized; according to ISO 17299-2:2014, the ammonia gas elimination rate reaches 99.9%, and the deodorant has a deodorization function.
Detailed Description
The present invention will be described in further detail with reference to specific examples. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are merely illustrative of the invention and are not intended to limit the invention.
Example 1:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 38% of SOL FR fiber, 30% of polyimide fiber, 30% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 2% of conductive fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the short-process spinning process is adopted, and the process flow is as follows: automatic cotton feeding → cotton carding → one drawing → two drawing → three drawing → four drawing → roving → spun yarn → automatic spooling, the yarn count of the obtained welding protective clothing fabric is 30/2S. Obtaining new three-proof fabric gray fabric through a weaving process, and obtaining new three-proof fabric through a specific dyeing process and a specific after-finishing process, wherein the gram weight of the new three-proof fabric gray fabric is 240g/m2The width is 1.5 m.
Example 2:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 29% of SOL FR fiber, 40% of polyimide fiber, 30% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 1% of conductive fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 1.
Example 3:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 43% of SOL FR fiber, 15% of polyimide fiber, 40% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 2% of conductive fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 1.
Example 4:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 47% of SOL FR fiber, 20% of polyimide fiber, 30% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 3% of conductive fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 1.
Example 5:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 36% of SOL FR fiber, 35% of polyimide fiber, 25% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 4% of conductive fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 1.
Example 6:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 35% of SOL FR fiber, 25% of polyimide fiber, 35% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 5% of conductive fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 1.
Example 7:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 45% of SOL FR fiber, 10% of polyimide fiber, 15% of pre-oxidized fiber and 30% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the short-process spinning process is adopted, and the process flow is as follows: automatic cotton feeding → cotton carding → one drawing → two drawing → three drawing → roving → spun yarn → automatic spooling, the yarn count of the obtained welding protective clothing fabric is 28/2S. Obtaining new three-proofing fabric gray fabric through a weaving process, and obtaining new three-proofing fabric through a specific dyeing process and a specific after-finishing process, wherein the gram weight of the new three-proofing fabric gray fabric is 220g/m2The width is 1.5 m.
Example 8:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 30% of SOL FR fiber, 20% of polyimide fiber, 20% of pre-oxidized fiber and 30% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 7.
Example 9:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 40% of SOFFR fiber, 30% of polyimide fiber, 10% of pre-oxidized fiber and 20% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 7.
Example 10:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 35% of SOL FR fiber, 10% of polyimide fiber, 20% of pre-oxidized fiber and 35% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 7.
Example 11:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 35% of SOL FR fiber, 15% of polyimide fiber, 25% of pre-oxidized fiber and 25% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 7.
Example 12:
a new three-proofing fabric comprises the following components in percentage by mass: 25% of SOL FR fiber, 25% of polyimide fiber, 30% of pre-oxidized fiber and 20% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 7.
Comparative example 1:
a single SOL FR fiber is provided.
The preparation method comprises the following steps: the same as in example 1.
The vertical burning, bacteriostasis and deodorization tests are carried out on the fabrics prepared by the above examples and comparative examples, and the results are as follows:
TABLE 1 vertical burning, bacteriostasis and deodorization test results of fabrics
Figure BDA0002341262930000051
From the above results, it can be derived:
the fabric blended by the SOL FR, the polyimide fibers, the pre-oxidized fibers, the flame-retardant acrylic fibers and the conductive fibers has good flame retardant property, the flame retardant grade of the blended fabric can reach A grade, and the antibacterial and deodorant properties are also good.

Claims (4)

1. The novel three-proofing fabric is characterized by being formed by blending the following components in percentage by mass: 20-60% of SOL FR, 10-40% of polyimide fiber, 20-50% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 1-5% of conductive fiber.
2. The novel three-proofing fabric according to claim 1, which is formed by blending the following components in percentage by mass: 30-50% of SOL FR, 20-40% of polyimide fiber, 25-40% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 1-5% of conductive fiber.
3. The novel three-proofing fabric is characterized by being formed by blending the following components in percentage by mass: 20-60% of SOL FR, 10-40% of polyimide fiber, 20-50% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 10-30% of pre-oxidized silk.
4. The novel three-proofing fabric as claimed in claim 3, which is prepared by blending the following components in percentage by mass: 30-50% of SOL FR, 15-30% of polyimide fiber, 20-40% of flame-retardant acrylic fiber and 15-25% of pre-oxidized silk.
CN201911377209.9A 2019-12-27 2019-12-27 Novel three-proofing fabric Pending CN113046892A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201911377209.9A CN113046892A (en) 2019-12-27 2019-12-27 Novel three-proofing fabric

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201911377209.9A CN113046892A (en) 2019-12-27 2019-12-27 Novel three-proofing fabric

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN113046892A true CN113046892A (en) 2021-06-29

Family

ID=76506315

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN201911377209.9A Pending CN113046892A (en) 2019-12-27 2019-12-27 Novel three-proofing fabric

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN113046892A (en)

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN114395841A (en) * 2022-01-06 2022-04-26 深圳市威仕度服装有限公司 Composite flame-retardant fabric and protective clothing based on same

Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN101724964A (en) * 2009-11-19 2010-06-09 汕头市奥山服饰有限公司 High-temperature resistant flame-retarding textile
WO2014025601A1 (en) * 2012-08-10 2014-02-13 Mmi-Ipco, Llc Flame resistant fiber blends and flame resistant yarns, fabrics, and garments formed thereof
CN105350133A (en) * 2015-09-28 2016-02-24 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 Blending of organic silicone-nitrogen flame-retardant viscose staple fibers and polyimide fibers
CN106222775A (en) * 2016-07-26 2016-12-14 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 A kind of fire-retardant regenerated celulose fibre of organic silazane
CN107254720A (en) * 2017-07-04 2017-10-17 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 A kind of far-infrared anti-biotic organic silazane fire resistance fibre and its production method
CN108754786A (en) * 2018-07-16 2018-11-06 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 A kind of multifunctional flame-proof blanket and preparation method thereof
CN108823667A (en) * 2018-07-16 2018-11-16 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 Multielement synergistic flame retardant and the manufacturing process for regenerating flame retardant cellulose fiber

Patent Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN101724964A (en) * 2009-11-19 2010-06-09 汕头市奥山服饰有限公司 High-temperature resistant flame-retarding textile
WO2014025601A1 (en) * 2012-08-10 2014-02-13 Mmi-Ipco, Llc Flame resistant fiber blends and flame resistant yarns, fabrics, and garments formed thereof
CN105350133A (en) * 2015-09-28 2016-02-24 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 Blending of organic silicone-nitrogen flame-retardant viscose staple fibers and polyimide fibers
CN106222775A (en) * 2016-07-26 2016-12-14 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 A kind of fire-retardant regenerated celulose fibre of organic silazane
CN107254720A (en) * 2017-07-04 2017-10-17 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 A kind of far-infrared anti-biotic organic silazane fire resistance fibre and its production method
CN108754786A (en) * 2018-07-16 2018-11-06 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 A kind of multifunctional flame-proof blanket and preparation method thereof
CN108823667A (en) * 2018-07-16 2018-11-16 北京赛欧兰阻燃纤维有限公司 Multielement synergistic flame retardant and the manufacturing process for regenerating flame retardant cellulose fiber

Non-Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
眭伟民等: "《阻燃纤维及织物》", 30 April 1990, 纺织工业出版社 *

Cited By (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN114395841A (en) * 2022-01-06 2022-04-26 深圳市威仕度服装有限公司 Composite flame-retardant fabric and protective clothing based on same
CN114395841B (en) * 2022-01-06 2023-08-29 深圳市威仕度服装有限公司 Composite flame-retardant fabric and protective clothing based on same

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN108315859B (en) Efficient arc protection fabric and preparation method thereof
CN104630958B (en) Fabric made from the flame-retardant yarn of polymer blend fiber comprising aromatic polyamide and polyarylsulfone (PAS) and and preparation method
JP6162463B2 (en) Spun yarn and fabric and apparel
KR20130131382A (en) Flame resistant fabric for protective clothing
CN101397710A (en) Industrial flame-retardant protection suit fabric, production method thereof and flame-retardant protection suit thereof
CN110396748B (en) High-temperature-resistant yarn, composite fabric and protective fabric
CN102634904A (en) Polyester fiber blended or interwoven fabric with flame retardant property and molten drop resistance
CN110273209B (en) High-strength flame-retardant high-temperature-resistant polyimide yarn and preparation method thereof
CN109797474B (en) Molten metal splashing protection fabric and manufacturing method thereof
CN106400266A (en) Multi-component low-cost permanent inflaming retarding fabric and preparation method for same
CN110055659B (en) Comfortable anti-electric arc fabric and preparation method thereof
CN108754786B (en) Multifunctional flame-retardant blanket and preparation method thereof
CN107160751A (en) A kind of aramid fabric of the anti-metal drop of fire-retardant fireproof
CN104630959B (en) Yarn, fabric and preparation method comprising a kind of blended fiber based on aromatic polyamide and polyarylsulfone (PAS) and cellulose fibre
CN113046892A (en) Novel three-proofing fabric
CN108166119A (en) The fire-retardant blend of comfort arc protection
CN109576868B (en) Anti-electric arc fabric and preparation method thereof
CN214300543U (en) Flame-retardant yarn, corresponding flame-retardant fabric and garment
CN112458583B (en) Para-aramid fiber, preparation method thereof and application of para-aramid fiber in preparation of molten metal splash protection clothing
WO2014107750A1 (en) Flame resistant fabric for protective clothing and upholstery applications and its use
CN106939466A (en) It is a kind of that there is permanent fire retardant multifunctional fabric of improvement comfortableness and preparation method thereof
EP3245320B1 (en) Flame resistant fabric
CN108166118B (en) Economical material flame retardant blends
CN110725041B (en) Welding anti-splashing fabric and preparation method thereof
JP6162462B2 (en) Spun yarn and fabric and apparel

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
WD01 Invention patent application deemed withdrawn after publication

Application publication date: 20210629

WD01 Invention patent application deemed withdrawn after publication