CN107556723A - Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof - Google Patents

Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN107556723A
CN107556723A CN201710670216.2A CN201710670216A CN107556723A CN 107556723 A CN107556723 A CN 107556723A CN 201710670216 A CN201710670216 A CN 201710670216A CN 107556723 A CN107556723 A CN 107556723A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
parts
fire
air conditioner
control panel
automobile air
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
CN201710670216.2A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
王红胜
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Shenzhen Wohaisen Technology Co Ltd
Original Assignee
Shenzhen Wohaisen Technology Co Ltd
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Shenzhen Wohaisen Technology Co Ltd filed Critical Shenzhen Wohaisen Technology Co Ltd
Priority to CN201710670216.2A priority Critical patent/CN107556723A/en
Publication of CN107556723A publication Critical patent/CN107556723A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Landscapes

  • Compositions Of Macromolecular Compounds (AREA)

Abstract

The invention discloses fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of a kind of high rigidity and preparation method thereof, it is related to automobile air conditioner case technical field, the sheathing material is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:70 80 parts of PC, 38 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 20 30 parts of composite modifier, 0.5 2 parts of Tissuemat E, 13 parts of titanate coupling agent, 5 10 parts of diatomite, 0.5 2 parts of antioxidant, 0.5 2 parts of fire retardant;The composite modifier is ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide composite modifier; automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material prepared by the present invention has good hardness and resistance to marring; its product surface pencil hardness is up to 2H; its surface tear is not easily caused when wiping cleaning; the requirement of automobile air conditioner control panel shell damage resistant, high fire-retardance is disclosure satisfy that, and preparation method is simple.

Description

Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof
Technical field
The present invention relates to automobile air conditioner case technical field, and in particular to a kind of fire-retardant air conditioning for automobiles chain of command of high rigidity Plate sheathing material and preparation method thereof.
Background technology
With the continuous development of automobile industry, automobile has turned into the preferred traffic instrument of people's trip, because summer is hot Weather frequently result in in-car too high temperature of air, cooling processing is carried out to it using air conditioning for automobiles for this, solved above-mentioned Problem, existing automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material are formed using plastic processing more.
Makrolon(PC)It is the high molecular polymer containing carbonate group in strand, is in existing five large-engineering plastics The most fast general engineering plastic of growth rate, PC have high impact strength and excellent machinery, heat, electric combination property, extensively For automobile, Aero-Space, medicine equipment, electronic apparatus, electrical equipment household electrical appliances, display casing, communication apparatus case spare part etc. Other field, still, the resistance to scratch of PC materials are poor, and be exposed in ultraviolet to turn to be yellow for a long time, at present, be typically utilized in PC Surface applies last layer nano paint and improves PC hardness, but this method complex procedures, troublesome in poeration, can make product produce compared with Big internal stress, and PC is to notch sensitive, product is easy to ftracture, and its application is restricted, and with people's awareness of safety Continuous improvement, it is slow or nonflammable also to require that sheathing material burns in fire.
The content of the invention
In view of the shortcomings of the prior art, the invention provides shell material outside a kind of fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel of high rigidity Material and preparation method thereof.
To realize object above, the present invention is achieved by the following technical programs:
A kind of fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:PC 70-80 Part, polyphenylene sulfide 3-8 parts, composite modifier 20-30 parts, Tissuemat E 0.5-2 parts, titanate coupling agent 1-3 parts, diatomite 5- 10 parts, antioxidant 0.5-2 parts, fire retardant 0.5-2 parts;The composite modifier is that ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide is multiple Close modifying agent.
Preferably, it is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:76 parts of PC, 6 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 24 parts of composite modifier, poly- second 1 part of alkene wax, 1.5 parts of titanate coupling agent, 7 parts of diatomite, 1 part of antioxidant, 1.2 parts of fire retardant.
Preferably, the preparation method of the composite modifier is as follows:Add graphene oxide into toluene, ultrasound point Dissipate, stirred using high speed homogenization mixer, obtain 1-5% graphene oxide dispersion;By the 1-5% second of 3- aminopropyls three The ethanol solution of TMOS is added in graphene oxide dispersion, stirring while adding, after reaction terminates, is filtered, is used Water washing, vacuum drying, obtains modified graphene oxide;By ABS, vitreous fiber, diaminodiphenyl-methane and modified oxidized stone Black alkene mixes, and extrudes to obtain composite modifier through double screw extruder.
Preferably, the graphene oxide is added in toluene, ultrasonic disperse 20-40min, supersonic frequency 25- 30KHz。
Preferably, the mass ratio of the graphene oxide and APTES is 1:1-5.
Preferably, the reaction temperature of the graphite oxide and APTES is 70-80 DEG C, and stirring is anti- Answer 5-8h.
Preferably, the fire retardant is MCA and triphenyl phosphate according to 1:The mixture of 1-4 compositions.
The preparation method of the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, step are as follows:By PC, composite modified Agent is added in high mixer, mixes 7-15min, then adds polyphenylene sulfide mixing 3-5min, last addition polymerization ethylene waxes, titanate esters Coupling agent, diatomite, antioxidant, fire retardant, 7-15min is mixed, compound is obtained, adds mixture into double screw extruder Middle blending extrusion, is produced.
Beneficial effect:The present invention is modified using ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide composite modifier to PC, so as to Its intensity and case hardness are improved, improves scratch resistant performance;Composite flame-retardant agent and polyphenylene sulfide are used cooperatively, and are largely carried The high flame retarding efficiency of material, the automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of preparation have good hardness and resistance to marring, its Product surface pencil hardness is not easily caused its surface tear when wiping cleaning, disclosure satisfy that automobile air conditioner control panel up to 2H The requirement of shell damage resistant, high fire-retardance, its preparation method are simple.
Embodiment
To make the purpose, technical scheme and advantage of the embodiment of the present invention clearer, below in conjunction with the embodiment of the present invention, to this Technical scheme in inventive embodiments is clearly and completely described, it is clear that described embodiment is that a part of the invention is real Example, rather than whole embodiments are applied, based on the embodiment in the present invention, those of ordinary skill in the art are not making creation Property work under the premise of the every other embodiment that is obtained, belong to the scope of protection of the invention.
Embodiment 1:
A kind of fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:76 parts of PC, 6 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 24 parts of composite modifier, 1 part of Tissuemat E, 1.5 parts of titanate coupling agent, 7 parts of diatomite, antioxidant 1 Part, 1.2 parts of fire retardant;
Wherein, composite modifier is ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide composite modifier, and its preparation method is as follows:Will oxidation Graphene is added in toluene, ultrasonic disperse 30min under 25KHz, is stirred using high speed homogenization mixer, obtains 2% oxidation Graphene dispersing solution;The ethanol solution of 3% APTES is added to graphene oxide dispersion In, the mass ratio of graphene oxide and APTES is 1:2, stirring while adding, stirring reaction 7h, reaction Temperature is 75 DEG C, after reaction terminates, filters, is washed with water, is dried in vacuo, obtains modified graphene oxide;By ABS, vitreous fiber, Diaminodiphenyl-methane and modified graphene oxide mix, and extrude to obtain composite modifier through double screw extruder.
Wherein, fire retardant is MCA and triphenyl phosphate according to 1:The mixture of 3 compositions.
The preparation method of the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, step are as follows:By PC, composite modified Agent is added in high mixer, mixes 8min, then adds polyphenylene sulfide mixing 5min, last addition polymerization ethylene waxes, titanate esters coupling Agent, diatomite, antioxidant, fire retardant, 10min is mixed, compound is obtained, adds mixture into double screw extruder and be blended Extrusion, is produced.
Embodiment 2:
A kind of fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:72 parts of PC, 5 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 27 parts of composite modifier, 0.8 part of Tissuemat E, 1.2 parts of titanate coupling agent, 8 parts of diatomite, antioxidant 0.8 part, 1.5 parts of fire retardant;
Wherein, composite modifier is ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide composite modifier, and its preparation method is as follows:Will oxidation Graphene is added in toluene, ultrasonic disperse 20min under 27KHz, is stirred using high speed homogenization mixer, obtains 5% oxidation Graphene dispersing solution;The ethanol solution of 5% APTES is added to graphene oxide dispersion In, the mass ratio of graphene oxide and APTES is 1:1, stirring while adding, stirring reaction 8h, reaction Temperature is 70 DEG C, after reaction terminates, filters, is washed with water, is dried in vacuo, obtains modified graphene oxide;By ABS, vitreous fiber, Diaminodiphenyl-methane and modified graphene oxide mix, and extrude to obtain composite modifier through double screw extruder.
Wherein, fire retardant is MCA and triphenyl phosphate according to 1:The mixture of 2 compositions.
The preparation method of the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, step are as follows:By PC, composite modified Agent is added in high mixer, mixes 15min, then adds polyphenylene sulfide mixing 4min, last addition polymerization ethylene waxes, titanate esters coupling Agent, diatomite, antioxidant, fire retardant, 10min is mixed, compound is obtained, adds mixture into double screw extruder and be blended Extrusion, is produced.
Embodiment 3:
A kind of fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:70 parts of PC, 8 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 20 parts of composite modifier, 2 parts of Tissuemat E, 1 part of titanate coupling agent, 10 parts of diatomite, antioxidant 0.5 Part, 2 parts of fire retardant;
Wherein, composite modifier is ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide composite modifier, and its preparation method is as follows:Will oxidation Graphene is added in toluene, ultrasonic disperse 35min under 28KHz, is stirred using high speed homogenization mixer, obtains 5% oxidation Graphene dispersing solution;The ethanol solution of 1% APTES is added to graphene oxide dispersion In, the mass ratio of graphene oxide and APTES is 1:5, stirring while adding, stirring reaction 6h, reaction Temperature is 75 DEG C, after reaction terminates, filters, is washed with water, is dried in vacuo, obtains modified graphene oxide;By ABS, vitreous fiber, Diaminodiphenyl-methane and modified graphene oxide mix, and extrude to obtain composite modifier through double screw extruder.
Wherein, fire retardant is MCA and triphenyl phosphate according to 1:The mixture of 1 composition.
The preparation method of the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, step are as follows:By PC, composite modified Agent is added in high mixer, mixes 7min, then adds polyphenylene sulfide mixing 5min, last addition polymerization ethylene waxes, titanate esters coupling Agent, diatomite, antioxidant, fire retardant, 15min is mixed, compound is obtained, adds mixture into double screw extruder and be blended Extrusion, is produced.
Embodiment 4:
A kind of fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, is made up of the raw material of following parts by weight:80 parts of PC, 3 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 30 parts of composite modifier, 0.5 part of Tissuemat E, 3 parts of titanate coupling agent, 5 parts of diatomite, antioxidant 2 Part, 0.5 part of fire retardant;
Wherein, composite modifier is ABS/ vitreous fiber/graphene oxide composite modifier, and its preparation method is as follows:Will oxidation Graphene is added in toluene, ultrasonic disperse 40min under 30KHz, is stirred using high speed homogenization mixer, obtains 3% oxidation Graphene dispersing solution;The ethanol solution of 3% APTES is added to graphene oxide dispersion In, the mass ratio of graphene oxide and APTES is 1:4, stirring while adding, stirring reaction 5h, reaction Temperature is 80 DEG C, after reaction terminates, filters, is washed with water, is dried in vacuo, obtains modified graphene oxide;By ABS, vitreous fiber, Diaminodiphenyl-methane and modified graphene oxide mix, and extrude to obtain composite modifier through double screw extruder.
Wherein, fire retardant is MCA and triphenyl phosphate according to 1:The mixture of 4 compositions.
The preparation method of the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity, step are as follows:By PC, composite modified Agent is added in high mixer, mixes 10min, then adds polyphenylene sulfide mixing 3min, last addition polymerization ethylene waxes, titanate esters coupling Agent, diatomite, antioxidant, fire retardant, 7min is mixed, compound is obtained, adds mixture into double screw extruder and be blended Extrusion, is produced.
The above embodiments are merely illustrative of the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than its limitations;Although with reference to the foregoing embodiments The present invention is described in detail, it will be understood by those within the art that:It still can be to foregoing each implementation Technical scheme described in example is modified, or carries out equivalent substitution to which part technical characteristic;And these modification or Replace, the essence of appropriate technical solution is departed from the spirit and scope of various embodiments of the present invention technical scheme.

Claims (8)

1. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of a kind of high rigidity, it is characterised in that by the raw material of following parts by weight It is made:PC 70-80 parts, polyphenylene sulfide 3-8 parts, composite modifier 20-30 parts, Tissuemat E 0.5-2 parts, titanate coupling agent 1-3 parts, diatomite 5-10 parts, antioxidant 0.5-2 parts, fire retardant 0.5-2 parts;The composite modifier is that ABS/ vitreous is fine Dimension/graphene oxide composite modifier.
2. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as claimed in claim 1, it is characterised in that by following The raw material of parts by weight is made:76 parts of PC, 6 parts of polyphenylene sulfide, 24 parts of composite modifier, 1 part of Tissuemat E, titanate coupling agent 1.5 parts, 7 parts of diatomite, 1 part of antioxidant, 1.2 parts of fire retardant.
3. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as claimed in claim 1 or 2, it is characterised in that institute The preparation method for stating composite modifier is as follows:Add graphene oxide into toluene, ultrasonic disperse, stirred using high speed homogenization Machine stirs, and obtains 1-5% graphene oxide dispersion;By the absolute ethyl alcohol of 1-5% APTES Solution is added in graphene oxide dispersion, stirring while adding, after reaction terminates, is filtered, is washed with water, is dried in vacuo, obtains Modified graphene oxide;ABS, vitreous fiber, diaminodiphenyl-methane and modified graphene oxide are mixed, squeezed through twin-screw Go out machine to extrude to obtain composite modifier.
4. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as claimed in claim 3, it is characterised in that the oxygen Graphite alkene is added in toluene, ultrasonic disperse 20-40min, supersonic frequency 25-30KHz.
5. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as claimed in claim 3, it is characterised in that the oxygen The mass ratio of graphite alkene and APTES is 1:1-5.
6. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as claimed in claim 3, it is characterised in that the oxygen Graphite and the reaction temperature of APTES are 70-80 DEG C, stirring reaction 5-8h.
7. the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as claimed in claim 1 or 2, it is characterised in that institute It is MCA and triphenyl phosphate according to 1 to state fire retardant:The mixture of 1-4 compositions.
8. the preparation method of the fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity as described in claim 1-7 is any, Characterized in that, step is as follows:PC, composite modifier are added in high mixer, 7-15min is mixed, then adds polyphenylene sulfide Ether mixing 3-5min, last addition polymerization ethylene waxes, titanate coupling agent, diatomite, antioxidant, fire retardant, 7-15min is mixed, Compound is obtained, blending extrusion in double screw extruder is added mixture into, produces.
CN201710670216.2A 2017-08-08 2017-08-08 Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof Pending CN107556723A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201710670216.2A CN107556723A (en) 2017-08-08 2017-08-08 Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201710670216.2A CN107556723A (en) 2017-08-08 2017-08-08 Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN107556723A true CN107556723A (en) 2018-01-09

Family

ID=60975164

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN201710670216.2A Pending CN107556723A (en) 2017-08-08 2017-08-08 Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN107556723A (en)

Cited By (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN108299819A (en) * 2018-03-21 2018-07-20 合肥东恒锐电子科技有限公司 A kind of good counter body material of intensity high-termal conductivity and preparation method thereof
CN108342047A (en) * 2018-02-06 2018-07-31 合肥东恒锐电子科技有限公司 A kind of preparation method of counter body material

Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2010059340A (en) * 2008-09-05 2010-03-18 Mitsubishi Engineering Plastics Corp Aromatic polycarbonate resin composition, and molded product and housing formed of the same
CN102093685A (en) * 2009-12-12 2011-06-15 拜尔材料科学股份公司 Polycarbonate compositions with improved surface hardness
CN102358800A (en) * 2011-09-15 2012-02-22 苏州铧茂工程塑料有限公司 Halogen free flame retardant PC / ABS alloy and preparation method thereof
CN102558808A (en) * 2010-12-28 2012-07-11 合肥杰事杰新材料股份有限公司 Environment-friendly flame-retardant scratch-resistant polycarbonate resin and preparation method thereof
WO2014014590A1 (en) * 2012-07-16 2014-01-23 Baker Hughes Incorporated High glass transition temperature thermoset and method of making the same
CN103553028A (en) * 2013-10-24 2014-02-05 深圳市沃特新材料股份有限公司 Graphene capable of being stably compounded with engineering plastics, and composite engineering plastics
CN106751681A (en) * 2016-12-27 2017-05-31 天津金发新材料有限公司 A kind of low gloss, scratch-resistant, high tenacity fire retardation PC/ABS compositions

Patent Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2010059340A (en) * 2008-09-05 2010-03-18 Mitsubishi Engineering Plastics Corp Aromatic polycarbonate resin composition, and molded product and housing formed of the same
CN102093685A (en) * 2009-12-12 2011-06-15 拜尔材料科学股份公司 Polycarbonate compositions with improved surface hardness
CN102558808A (en) * 2010-12-28 2012-07-11 合肥杰事杰新材料股份有限公司 Environment-friendly flame-retardant scratch-resistant polycarbonate resin and preparation method thereof
CN102358800A (en) * 2011-09-15 2012-02-22 苏州铧茂工程塑料有限公司 Halogen free flame retardant PC / ABS alloy and preparation method thereof
WO2014014590A1 (en) * 2012-07-16 2014-01-23 Baker Hughes Incorporated High glass transition temperature thermoset and method of making the same
CN103553028A (en) * 2013-10-24 2014-02-05 深圳市沃特新材料股份有限公司 Graphene capable of being stably compounded with engineering plastics, and composite engineering plastics
CN106751681A (en) * 2016-12-27 2017-05-31 天津金发新材料有限公司 A kind of low gloss, scratch-resistant, high tenacity fire retardation PC/ABS compositions

Non-Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
董相茂,等: "高韧性高刚性玻璃纤维增强聚碳酸酯的研究", 《塑料工业》 *

Cited By (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN108342047A (en) * 2018-02-06 2018-07-31 合肥东恒锐电子科技有限公司 A kind of preparation method of counter body material
CN108299819A (en) * 2018-03-21 2018-07-20 合肥东恒锐电子科技有限公司 A kind of good counter body material of intensity high-termal conductivity and preparation method thereof

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN109438804A (en) A kind of flame retardant plastics master batch and preparation method thereof
CN110591335B (en) High-flame-retardance low-smoke-toxicity weather-resistant cable sheath material and preparation method thereof
CN108410066B (en) SiO (silicon dioxide)2Preparation method of nano particle modified expandable graphite and flame-retardant polypropylene
CN113105679B (en) Corrugated pipe filling master batch, preparation method and application
CN110951163A (en) High-surface-tension low-density polypropylene composite material and preparation method thereof
CN106009144A (en) High-thermal-conductivity polyolefin resin based composite material and preparation method thereof
CN105820754A (en) Flame-retardant waterproof interior wall coating and preparation method thereof
CN107556723A (en) Fire-retardant automobile air conditioner control panel sheathing material of high rigidity and preparation method thereof
CN109575427A (en) A kind of low-luster polypropylene composite material and preparation method thereof
JPH0118091B2 (en)
CN106433067B (en) A kind of formula and preparation method thereof of environment-friendly type PC/ABS alloy materials
CN110746700A (en) Antibacterial reinforced color master batch for polypropylene and preparation method thereof
CN105385070A (en) Wire and cable sheath processing technology based on nano calcium carbonate
CN108623916A (en) A kind of heat-resisting PP plastics of the halogen-free flameproof of environment-friendly degradable and preparation method thereof
CN108892931A (en) A kind of high pressure resistant cable jacking and preparation method thereof
CN105218970B (en) A kind of antistatic PVC base wood-plastic composite materials and preparation method thereof
CN107513213A (en) A kind of electrician's panel PP composite material and preparation method thereof
CN107446368A (en) Using silane-modified boehmite as wood plastic composite of fire retardant and preparation method thereof
CN106977896A (en) A kind of wear-resisting PC ABS alloy materials and preparation method thereof
CN107857976A (en) A kind of electric power infrastructure erosion resisting insulation material
CN108949064A (en) A kind of high foaming rate automobile PVC foam primary coat glue and preparation method thereof
CN105733231A (en) Calcium sulfate whisker-modified polycarbonate alloy material and preparation method thereof
CN108752923A (en) A kind of novel flame-retardant antimicrobial composite material and its preparation process
CN110408106A (en) A kind of blending type cable sheath material and preparation method thereof
CN113549290B (en) Modified HIPS material for integral molding of oil-resistant and corrosion-resistant refrigerator body

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
WD01 Invention patent application deemed withdrawn after publication

Application publication date: 20180109

WD01 Invention patent application deemed withdrawn after publication