CN103852647A - Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field - Google Patents

Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN103852647A
CN103852647A CN201210513662.XA CN201210513662A CN103852647A CN 103852647 A CN103852647 A CN 103852647A CN 201210513662 A CN201210513662 A CN 201210513662A CN 103852647 A CN103852647 A CN 103852647A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
return stroke
lightning
approximate
field
lightning return
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
CN201210513662.XA
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
陈亚洲
万浩江
王晓嘉
程二威
关闯
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Ordnance Engineering College of PLA
Original Assignee
Ordnance Engineering College of PLA
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Ordnance Engineering College of PLA filed Critical Ordnance Engineering College of PLA
Priority to CN201210513662.XA priority Critical patent/CN103852647A/en
Publication of CN103852647A publication Critical patent/CN103852647A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Images

Landscapes

  • Management, Administration, Business Operations System, And Electronic Commerce (AREA)

Abstract

The invention provides an approximate analysis expressing method for a lightning return stroke electromagnetic field. Approximate analysis expressions for the lightning return stroke electromagnetic field are composed of the approximate analysis expression for a lightning near-zone electric field, the approximate analysis expression for a near-zone magnetic field, the approximate analysis expression for a far-zone electric field and the approximate analysis expression for a far-zone magnetic field. Based on a transmission line model in the lightning return stroke process, approximate treatment is performed on an accurate analysis expression for the lightning return stroke electromagnetic field to obtain the set of approximate analysis expressions, wherein the accurate analysis expression is obtained through a dipole method. In the set of approximate analysis expressions, whether the near-zone field or the far-zone field, the earth surface lightning return stroke electromagnetic field can be approximately expressed as the product of a function of the channel bottom currents and a factor related with the distance. The set of approximate analysis expressions for the lightning return stroke electromagnetic field provide a theoretical basis for approximate calculation for the lightning return stroke electromagnetic field, development of a laboratory lightning return stroke electromagnetic field and a magnetic field simulator and remote evaluation performed on lightning return stroke parameters.

Description

A kind of approximate analysis expression of Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke
Technical field
The invention provides the approximate analysis expression formula of one group of earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, is the product of lightning channel base current and and Range-based factor by Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke approximate representation.The method can be applicable to approximate treatment, the development of thunder and lightning electro-magnetic environment simulator and the remote approximate evaluation of Fields of Lightning Return Stroke parameter of earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke.
Background technology
Be accompanied by the develop rapidly of infotech, the electromagnetic susceptibility of various electronic equipments is more and more higher, and the Lightning Electromagnetic Pulse (LEMP) that Return stroke of ground flash produces endangers source as a kind of typical case of electromagnetic susceptibility product and caused people's extensive concern.The contingency occurring due to thunder and lightning is very strong, and very difficult actual measurement obtains fighting back parameatal Lightning Electromagnetic Fields distribution situation, and more feasible method is that Fields of Lightning Return Stroke process is carried out calculating its electromagnetic field after theoretical modeling.Thunder discharge model can be divided into aerodynamics model, electromagnetic model, distributed circuit model and engineering model four classes.Wherein, engineering model is described as longitudinal current the function of height and time, is most widely used.At present, engineering model mainly comprises BG model, TL model, TCS model, MTLL model, MTLE model and DU model etc.Except the direction of motion and producing method of electric current, the key distinction of different engineering models is that the velocity of propagation of return stroke current is different with the attenuation law along passage.Solution of electro-magnetic field analysis method based on these engineering models mainly contains the separation of variable, conformal mapping method, monopole method and dipole technique etc.Wherein, the error of monopole technology is compared with recommendation greatly and not; Analytic solution and measured result by the ground Lightning Electromagnetic Fields to being obtained by dipole theory contrast, and confirm that dipole method has good computational accuracy.Therefore, dipole technique is widely used in antenna theory and Electromagnetic Calculation.
On above-mentioned basis of Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke being carried out to theoretical modeling and calculating, for further meeting the security test demand of the electromagnetic susceptibility products such as electronic and electrical equipment under thunder and lightning electromagnetic environment, need to carry out laboratory simulation to typical LEMP environment, in view of the lightning surge analogue technique in current laboratory comparatively ripe, the direct method that realizes so LEMP simulation is exactly to set up contacting between LEMP and Fields of Lightning Return Stroke channel bottom electric current, utilizes lightning surge analogue technique to realize the simulation of LEMP environment.The researchist of Florida university of the U.S. finds also to have proved theoretically the characteristic that LEMP far zone field and channel bottom electric current are approximate, thinks that the LEMP far zone field waveform in certain distance can carry out approximate representation with fighting back channel bottom current waveform; And find the approximate characteristic between electric field derivative and base current derivative in an artificially triggered lightning experiment.This just links up LEMP and Fields of Lightning Return Stroke channel bottom electric current.For further setting up theoretically earth's surface LEMP field wave shape and fighting back the relation between channel bottom current waveform, taking TL model as basis, carry out approximate processing by the LEMP field to being obtained by dipole method, provide a kind of utilization and fought back channel bottom current waveform and describe the approximate analysis expression formula of earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, and set it as the theoretical foundation of earth's surface LEMP approximate treatment and thunder and lightning electric field, the development of magnetic simulation device.
Summary of the invention
The technical problem to be solved in the present invention is directly perceived, the approximate contact of setting up between earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke and channel bottom current waveform, solve current thunder and lightning electromagnetic environment analogue technique and the realistic problem such as can comply with without standard, for the development of relevant simulator provides a kind of theoretical foundation.
For solving the problems of the technologies described above, the present invention is taking the Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke model of vertical channel as basis, be ideal conducting plane depending on the earth, accurate and analytical expression by the earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke to being obtained by dipole technique is carried out approximate processing, reject in Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke accurate and analytical expression base current function model has been chosen to comparatively responsive current integration item and current differential item, set up directly perceived between earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke expression formula and channel bottom current expression, approximate contact, between both expression formulas, only differ one with the factor of Range-based, concrete approximate expression is:
Figure BSA00000817060000022
Wherein, E z, H φrepresent respectively vertical electric field and poloidal magnetic field that Fields of Lightning Return Stroke produces on ground, and i (0, t) represent Fields of Lightning Return Stroke channel bottom electric current, ε 0represent the permittivity in vacuum, v, c represent respectively counterattack speed and the light velocity of lightning channel electric current, and r represents the horizontal range between Fields of Lightning Return Stroke passage and observation station.In far-field region, the ratio of the mould value of Electric and magnetic fields is
Figure BSA00000817060000023
the Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke that is far field can be approximately plane wave.
Advantage of the present invention is:
1) this group Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke approximate analysis expression formula has been rejected calculation of complex and negligible current integration item and differential term in accurate expression, reduce the requirement to return stroke current function model when Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke is calculated, greatly simplified the calculating of earth's surface LEMP.
2) can reflect comparatively intuitively the corresponding relation between Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke waveform and channel bottom current waveform, the simulation and the long-range detection Fields of Lightning Return Stroke parameter that can be laboratory Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke provide theoretical foundation.
Brief description of the drawings
Below in conjunction with the drawings and specific embodiments, the present invention is further detailed explanation.
Fig. 1 is the computation model of vertical channel Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke.
Fig. 2 is apart from the approximate comparison of wave shape figure of accurate electromagnetic field and its two-stage in the distance of counterattack path 10 m.
Fig. 3 is apart from the approximate comparison of wave shape figure of accurate electromagnetic field and its two-stage in the distance of counterattack passage 50km.
Embodiment
Fig. 1 is the computation model of vertical channel Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke: the vertical antenna that it is L that Fields of Lightning Return Stroke passage can be approximated to be perpendicular to the length on ground, return stroke current at the uniform velocity transmits along passage, suppose that the earth is the infinitely-great surface level of conductance, according to dipole technique, fight back any point (r on passage peripheral ground, φ, 0) general expression of the counterattack electromagnetic field of locating under cylindrical coordinate is
E z = 1 4 πϵ 0 ∫ - h h [ 2 z ′ 2 - r 2 R 5 ∫ - ∞ t i ( z ′ , t - R / c ) dt + 2 z ′ 2 - r 2 cR 4 i ( z ′ , t - R / c ) - r 2 c 2 R 3 ∂ i ( z ′ , t - R / c ) ∂ t ] dz ′ - - - ( 1 )
H φ = 1 4 π ∫ - h h [ r R 3 i ( z ′ , t - R / c ) + r cR 2 ∂ i ( z ′ , t - R / c ) ∂ t ] dz ′ - - - ( 2 )
Wherein, E zvertical electric field, H φbe poloidal magnetic field, r is the horizontal range of observation station apart from counterattack passage, and z ' is any point of fighting back in passage, and h is the height of z ' apart from earth's surface,
Figure BSA00000817060000026
for the distance between field point and electric current infinitesimal, c is the light velocity, and i is return stroke current.In formula (1), the 1st, the 2nd, the 3rd is respectively electrostatic field, induction field, radiation field; In formula (2), the 1st, the 2nd is respectively induction field, radiation field.To simplify the analysis, adopt transmission line (TL) model of Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, the mathematic(al) representation of return stroke current is
i(z′,t)=u(t-z′/v)·i(0,t-z′/v) (3)
Wherein, u (t-z '/v) be step function, v is current wave velocity of propagation.
The near field producing for Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, order
Figure BSA00000817060000031
according to TL model, the current integration item in electrostatic field component in formula (1)
∫ - ∞ t i ( z ′ , τ - R / c ) dτ = ∫ - ∞ t i ( 0 , τ - R / c - z ′ / v ) dτ = f ( 0 , t - R / c - z ′ / v ) - f ( 0,0 ) = F ( t - R / c - z ′ / v ) - - - ( 4 )
In near field, suppose r < < H, along with z ' increase, 1/R is tending towards 0 very soon.Like this F (t-R/c-z '/v) can the first approximation in t-r/c place Taylor expansion carry out linear expression by it,
F(t-R/c-z′/v)=F(t-r/c)-F′(t-r/c)×[(t-r/c)-(t-R/c-z′/v)]+o(c -2) (5)
≈F(t-r/c)-i(0,t-r/c)×[(R-r)/c+z′/v]
, electrostatic field and induction field can be distinguished approximate representation and be
E z &prime; ( electrostatic ) &ap; F ( t - r / c ) 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 h R ( h ) 3 - i ( 0 , t - r / c ) 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 [ 1 c ( rh R ( h ) 3 - 3 h 2 R ( h ) 2 + tan - 1 h r 2 r ) + 1 v ( r 2 R ( h ) 3 - 2 R ( h ) + 1 r ) ] - - - ( 6 )
E z &prime; ( induction ) &ap; i ( 0 , t - r / c ) 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 c [ tan - 1 ( h / r ) 2 r - 3 h 2 R ( h ) 2 ] - - - ( 7 )
Radiation field has been c 2magnitude, can ignore.So just obtain the first approximation expression formula of near region electric field
E z &prime; &ap; - F ( t - r / c ) 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 h R ( h ) 3 - i ( 0 , t - r / c ) 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 &times; [ rh cR ( h ) 3 + 1 v [ r 2 R ( h ) 3 - 2 R ( h ) + 1 r ] ] - - - ( 8 )
Similarly, can obtain the first approximation expression formula in magnetic field, near region
H &phi; &prime; &ap; H &phi; &prime; ( induction ) = 1 2 &pi; i ( 0 , t - r / c ) &Integral; 0 h r R 3 dz &prime; = 1 2 &pi;r i ( 0 , t - r / c ) h R ( h ) - - - ( 9 )
R < < H during due near field, along with the increase of time, electric current rises more and more higher in passage, and R (h) will level off to h; And ignore the R in formula (8) -1item and R -3, just can obtain the two stage approach expression formula of near region Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke
E z &prime; &prime; &ap; - 1 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 vr i ( 0 , t - r / c ) - - - ( 10 )
H &phi; &prime; &prime; &ap; 1 2 &pi;r i ( 0 , t - r / c ) - - - ( 11 )
The far zone field producing for Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, when R ≈ r and r > > L, the principal ingredient of LEMP electromagnetic field is radiation field, electrostatic field item and induction field item are tending towards 0.For the engineering model of transmission line type, because wavefront is continuous, formula (1), (2) are simplified, have
E z &prime; &prime; &ap; E z &prime; = E z ( radiation ) &ap; - 1 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 c 2 r &Integral; 0 h &PartialD; i ( 0 , t - r / c - z &prime; / v ) &PartialD; t dz &prime; - - - ( 12 )
H &phi; &prime; &prime; &ap; H &phi; &prime; &prime; = H &phi; ( radiation ) &ap; 1 2 &pi;cr &Integral; 0 h &PartialD; i ( 0 , t - r / c - z &prime; v ) &PartialD; t dz &prime; - - - ( 13 )
Because v is constant, so
&PartialD; i ( 0 , t - r / c - z &prime; / v ) &PartialD; t = - v &PartialD; i ( 0 , t - r / c - z &prime; / v ) &PartialD; z &prime; - - - ( 14 )
Formula (14) substitution formula (12), (13) integration are obtained
E z &prime; &prime; &ap; v 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 c 2 r &Integral; 0 h &PartialD; i ( 0 , t - r / c - z &prime; / v ) &PartialD; z &prime; dz &prime; = - v 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 c 2 r &times; [ i ( 0 , t - r / c ) - i ( 0 , t - r / c - h / v ) ] - - - ( 15 )
H &phi; &prime; &prime; &ap; - v 2 &pi;cr &Integral; 0 h &PartialD; i ( 0 , t - r / c - z &prime; / v ) &PartialD; z &prime; dz &prime; = v 2 &pi;cr &times; [ i ( 0 , t - r / c ) - i ( 0 , t - r / c - h / v ) ] - - - ( 16 )
Due to τ≤0 o'clock, i (0, τ)=0.In the time of t≤h/v+r/c, formula (15), (16) become
E z &prime; &prime; ( r , t ) &ap; E z ( radiation ) &ap; - v 2 &pi;&epsiv; 0 c 2 r i ( 0 , t - r / c ) - - - ( 17 )
H &phi; &prime; &prime; ( r , t ) &ap; H &phi; ( radiation ) &ap; v 2 &pi;cr i ( 0 , t - r / c ) - - - ( 18 )
Formula (10), (11) and formula (17), (18) are respectively the approximate analysis expression formula in thunder and lightning near region, earth's surface electric field, magnetic field, near region, far field electric field, magnetic field, far field.Wherein, the negative sign in electric field expression formula represents the direction of electric field and the opposite direction of current flowing.
Fig. 2 is apart from accurately the electromagnetic field comparison of wave shape figure approximate with its two-stage: Fig. 1 (a) and (b) the corresponding exact solution E that fights back Electromagnetic Calculation of waveform difference of middle numbering 1,2,3 in the distance of counterattack path 10 m z, H φ, first order approximate solution E ' z, H ' φ, and second order approximate solution E " z, H " φwaveform.
Fig. 3 be distance fight back in the distance of passage 50km the accurate electromagnetic field comparison of wave shape figure approximate with its two-stage: Fig. 2 (a) and (b) middle 1,2,3 the waveform of numbering represent respectively to fight back the exact solution E of Electromagnetic Calculation z, H φ, first order approximate solution (radiation field) E ' z, H ' φ, and second order approximate solution (base current of scale) E " z, H " φwaveform.
The comparing result of approximate expression waveform and exact solution waveform shows, no matter is near field region or far-field region, as long as return stroke current does not arrive counterattack channel roof, the waveform of electromagnetic field is just approximate consistent with the waveform of fighting back channel bottom electric current.

Claims (2)

1. be applied to an approximate analysis expression of describing earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, it is characterized in that:
Earth's surface of the present invention Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke approximate analysis expression formula, is made up of thunder and lightning near region electric field, magnetic field, near region, far field electric field and 4, magnetic field, far field approximate analysis expression formula; This group approximate analysis expression formula, taking the transmission line model of Fields of Lightning Return Stroke process as basis, obtains by the approximate processing of the Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke accurate and analytical expression to being obtained by dipole technique; In this group approximate analysis expression formula, no matter be near field or far zone field, earth's surface Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke all can approximate representation be the product of the factor of channel bottom electric current and and Range-based, and after observed range is determined, thunder and lightning Electric and magnetic fields waveform has similar features with counterattack channel bottom current waveform.
2. the approximate treatment, the theoretical foundation of laboratory Fields of Lightning Return Stroke Electric and magnetic fields simulator development etc. that the approximate analysis expression of above-mentioned Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke are applied to Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke, be also subject to the protection of this patent.
CN201210513662.XA 2012-11-29 2012-11-29 Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field Pending CN103852647A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201210513662.XA CN103852647A (en) 2012-11-29 2012-11-29 Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201210513662.XA CN103852647A (en) 2012-11-29 2012-11-29 Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN103852647A true CN103852647A (en) 2014-06-11

Family

ID=50860548

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN201210513662.XA Pending CN103852647A (en) 2012-11-29 2012-11-29 Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN103852647A (en)

Cited By (5)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN106156513A (en) * 2016-07-13 2016-11-23 成都信息工程大学 Ground dodges channel current decay and the method for FDTD method simulation radiated electric field
CN108037373A (en) * 2017-12-07 2018-05-15 南方电网科学研究院有限责任公司 The detection method and system of Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke
CN108427040A (en) * 2017-12-11 2018-08-21 海南电网有限责任公司琼海供电局 For the lightning detection method and device of power supply area
CN112131736A (en) * 2020-09-21 2020-12-25 中国电子科技网络信息安全有限公司 Lightning electromagnetic environment simulation modeling method
CN113866514A (en) * 2021-08-27 2021-12-31 国网电力科学研究院武汉南瑞有限责任公司 Thunder and lightning multi-physical effect synchronous fusion detection device and method

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2005274233A (en) * 2004-03-23 2005-10-06 Fujitsu Ltd Electromagnetic field simulator, electromagnetic field analyzer, electromagnetic field simulation program, and electromagnetic field analysis program
WO2007130205A2 (en) * 2006-05-04 2007-11-15 Exxonmobil Upstream Research Company Time lapse analysis with electromagnetic data
CN101261327A (en) * 2008-04-15 2008-09-10 何继善 All-zone couple source frequency domain magnetic depth measuring method and device

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2005274233A (en) * 2004-03-23 2005-10-06 Fujitsu Ltd Electromagnetic field simulator, electromagnetic field analyzer, electromagnetic field simulation program, and electromagnetic field analysis program
WO2007130205A2 (en) * 2006-05-04 2007-11-15 Exxonmobil Upstream Research Company Time lapse analysis with electromagnetic data
CN101261327A (en) * 2008-04-15 2008-09-10 何继善 All-zone couple source frequency domain magnetic depth measuring method and device

Non-Patent Citations (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
陈亚洲等: "地表LEMP及其导数的远场近似特性", 《高电压技术》, vol. 28, no. 5, 31 May 2002 (2002-05-31) *
陈亚洲等: "地表近场LEMP与回击电流的近似性", 《高电压技术》, vol. 33, no. 12, 31 December 2007 (2007-12-31) *

Cited By (5)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN106156513A (en) * 2016-07-13 2016-11-23 成都信息工程大学 Ground dodges channel current decay and the method for FDTD method simulation radiated electric field
CN108037373A (en) * 2017-12-07 2018-05-15 南方电网科学研究院有限责任公司 The detection method and system of Electromagnetic Fields of Lightning Return Stroke
CN108427040A (en) * 2017-12-11 2018-08-21 海南电网有限责任公司琼海供电局 For the lightning detection method and device of power supply area
CN112131736A (en) * 2020-09-21 2020-12-25 中国电子科技网络信息安全有限公司 Lightning electromagnetic environment simulation modeling method
CN113866514A (en) * 2021-08-27 2021-12-31 国网电力科学研究院武汉南瑞有限责任公司 Thunder and lightning multi-physical effect synchronous fusion detection device and method

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN108427041B (en) Lightning early warning method, system, electronic equipment and storage medium
CN103852647A (en) Approximate analysis expressing method for lightning return stroke electromagnetic field
CN102722178B (en) Electric field measuring obstacle avoidance system and method for live wire routing inspection of unmanned aerial vehicle
CN102736632B (en) Differential evadible system of electric field for unmanned aerial vehicle polling live wires and method
CN202046439U (en) Hedgehopping obstacle avoiding subsystem for electric line patrol unmanned helicopter
CN105244805A (en) Laser radar-based intelligent early-warning evaluation method and system for power transmission line
CN104597430B (en) Low-altitude wind shear three-dimensional backscattering wave simulation method for airborne meteorological radar
CN202632111U (en) Electric field measurement obstacle avoidance system for polling live wire by unmanned aerial vehicle
CN106707040B (en) A method of lightning parameter is obtained using actual measurement lightning vertical electric field
CN105372507B (en) A kind of electromagnetic environment method of real-time and system
Anisimov et al. Space charge and aeroelectric flows in the exchange layer: An experimental and numerical study
CN103235284A (en) Multi-station lightning VHF (very high frequency) radiation source three-dimensional positioning method and system
CN103245826A (en) Lightning induction voltage determining method and system on distributing lines
CN113868971B (en) Airport area three-dimensional refined wind field reconstruction method based on numerical simulation model and historical wind field characteristics
CN104569913A (en) High-precision full-lightning positioning method
CN103913680A (en) Partial discharging positioning method based on time delay error stochastic simulation and statistic analysis
US20200111382A1 (en) Automotive Radar Scene Simulator
CN110031828A (en) A kind of unmanned plane range-measurement system and method based on transmission line of electricity magnetic distribution
CN107148080A (en) A kind of quadratic programming localization method based on Heron&#39;s formula reference area residual error
CN113569751B (en) Dangerous rock mass identification method and device based on time-frequency domain dynamic parameters
CN104393588A (en) Minimum mean square error-based optimal PMU layout method
Wooi et al. Comparison of lightning return stroke channel-base current models with measured lightning current
CN108362926A (en) A kind of voltage class recognition methods and device
CN105629239B (en) The method that wind field turbulence intensity is estimated using airborne radar
Vahabi-Mashak et al. Modeling of time of arrival method for lightning locating systems

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
C06 Publication
PB01 Publication
C10 Entry into substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
RJ01 Rejection of invention patent application after publication
RJ01 Rejection of invention patent application after publication

Application publication date: 20140611